Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes

S. T. Oyama, D. Lee, P. Hacarlioglu, R. F. Saraf

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

133 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The promising properties of silica-based H 2-selective membranes have resulted in extensive experimental studies, but these investigations have provided limited information about the mechanism of gas permeation through these membranes. In this work we present a theory of permeation that describes the transport and physical properties of silica-based membranes of the Nanosil type. Nanosil membranes are obtained from the chemical vapor deposition of a thin silica layer on a porous support. The theory is adapted from an existing classical statistical mechanics treatment for vitreous silica glasses. It is found that in the Nanosil membranes the permeation of CO, CO 2 and CH 4 is inhibited relatively to that of smaller sized species such as hydrogen and the lighter noble gases. Moreover, the latter show an unusual order of gas permeation, He > H 2 > D 2 > Ne, which does not depend on the size or mass of the diffusing species. The theoretical description is based on jumps of the permeating species between solubility sites in a solid matrix, and assumes equilibrium sorption in the sites, random motion, and a transition state with two degrees of vibrational freedom and one degree of translational freedom. The adapted form of the theoretical equation has a term to account for the loss of rotational degrees of freedom for polyatomic species and is applicable to molecules such as H 2 or D 2. Agreement between theoretical values and experimentally determined points indicate that the model equations are effective in describing the unusual behavior of hydrogen and the light noble gases. The higher permeation rate of He over H 2 or D 2 can be accounted for by the larger number of solubility sites that can accommodate the smaller sized He atoms. The lower permeation rate of Ne is due to its lower jump frequency when compared with the vibrational frequency of the other species. The density of solubility sites and the jump distance are important parameters in this analysis. The amorphous structure of silica is formed of 5-, 6-, 7- and 8-membered Si-O bonded rings and gives rise to solubility sites whose size is approximately 0.3 nm. The jump distance should have an inverse relationship with the number of solubility sites per unit volume, but so far this has not been calculated explicitly. In this work, we apply the Perkus-Yevick treatment to a collection of randomly-distributed, non-interacting sites embedded in a solid to clarify this relationship. Our analysis shows that the jump distances used in previous descriptions of vitreous glasses are smaller than the predictions from an array of points of zero volume, which is not possible. On the other hand, the jump distances in our membranes were calculated to be around 0.8 nm, which are physically realistic. The number of solubility sites (N s ∼ 10 26 m -3) was found to be smaller by about one order of magnitude than in vitreous glasses, while the vibrational frequencies, stayed relatively unchanged. The activation energies for permeation through the silica membrane were also smaller than the ones through glass and indicate the presence of a totally different structure. The Nanosil membrane is probably formed of larger Si-O rings which give rise to more open and less dense structures.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)45-53
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Membrane Science
Volume244
Issue number1-2
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 15 2004
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Silicon Dioxide
Hydrogen
Permeability
Permeation
permeability
Silica
Solubility
silicon dioxide
membranes
Membranes
solubility
hydrogen
Glass
Noble Gases
Vibrational spectra
Carbon Monoxide
Fused silica
Inert gases
glass
rare gases

Keywords

  • Alumina
  • Hydrogen permeability
  • Percus-Yevick treatment
  • Silica
  • Solubility sites
  • Statistical mechanics theory

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biochemistry
  • Materials Science(all)
  • Physical and Theoretical Chemistry
  • Filtration and Separation

Cite this

Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes. / Oyama, S. T.; Lee, D.; Hacarlioglu, P.; Saraf, R. F.

In: Journal of Membrane Science, Vol. 244, No. 1-2, 15.11.2004, p. 45-53.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Oyama, S. T. ; Lee, D. ; Hacarlioglu, P. ; Saraf, R. F. / Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes. In: Journal of Membrane Science. 2004 ; Vol. 244, No. 1-2. pp. 45-53.
@article{ea357cf519ca4e9baaa6c8e103c96756,
title = "Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes",
abstract = "The promising properties of silica-based H 2-selective membranes have resulted in extensive experimental studies, but these investigations have provided limited information about the mechanism of gas permeation through these membranes. In this work we present a theory of permeation that describes the transport and physical properties of silica-based membranes of the Nanosil type. Nanosil membranes are obtained from the chemical vapor deposition of a thin silica layer on a porous support. The theory is adapted from an existing classical statistical mechanics treatment for vitreous silica glasses. It is found that in the Nanosil membranes the permeation of CO, CO 2 and CH 4 is inhibited relatively to that of smaller sized species such as hydrogen and the lighter noble gases. Moreover, the latter show an unusual order of gas permeation, He > H 2 > D 2 > Ne, which does not depend on the size or mass of the diffusing species. The theoretical description is based on jumps of the permeating species between solubility sites in a solid matrix, and assumes equilibrium sorption in the sites, random motion, and a transition state with two degrees of vibrational freedom and one degree of translational freedom. The adapted form of the theoretical equation has a term to account for the loss of rotational degrees of freedom for polyatomic species and is applicable to molecules such as H 2 or D 2. Agreement between theoretical values and experimentally determined points indicate that the model equations are effective in describing the unusual behavior of hydrogen and the light noble gases. The higher permeation rate of He over H 2 or D 2 can be accounted for by the larger number of solubility sites that can accommodate the smaller sized He atoms. The lower permeation rate of Ne is due to its lower jump frequency when compared with the vibrational frequency of the other species. The density of solubility sites and the jump distance are important parameters in this analysis. The amorphous structure of silica is formed of 5-, 6-, 7- and 8-membered Si-O bonded rings and gives rise to solubility sites whose size is approximately 0.3 nm. The jump distance should have an inverse relationship with the number of solubility sites per unit volume, but so far this has not been calculated explicitly. In this work, we apply the Perkus-Yevick treatment to a collection of randomly-distributed, non-interacting sites embedded in a solid to clarify this relationship. Our analysis shows that the jump distances used in previous descriptions of vitreous glasses are smaller than the predictions from an array of points of zero volume, which is not possible. On the other hand, the jump distances in our membranes were calculated to be around 0.8 nm, which are physically realistic. The number of solubility sites (N s ∼ 10 26 m -3) was found to be smaller by about one order of magnitude than in vitreous glasses, while the vibrational frequencies, stayed relatively unchanged. The activation energies for permeation through the silica membrane were also smaller than the ones through glass and indicate the presence of a totally different structure. The Nanosil membrane is probably formed of larger Si-O rings which give rise to more open and less dense structures.",
keywords = "Alumina, Hydrogen permeability, Percus-Yevick treatment, Silica, Solubility sites, Statistical mechanics theory",
author = "Oyama, {S. T.} and D. Lee and P. Hacarlioglu and Saraf, {R. F.}",
year = "2004",
month = "11",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.memsci.2004.06.046",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "244",
pages = "45--53",
journal = "Jornal of Membrane Science",
issn = "0376-7388",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Theory of hydrogen permeability in nonporous silica membranes

AU - Oyama, S. T.

AU - Lee, D.

AU - Hacarlioglu, P.

AU - Saraf, R. F.

PY - 2004/11/15

Y1 - 2004/11/15

N2 - The promising properties of silica-based H 2-selective membranes have resulted in extensive experimental studies, but these investigations have provided limited information about the mechanism of gas permeation through these membranes. In this work we present a theory of permeation that describes the transport and physical properties of silica-based membranes of the Nanosil type. Nanosil membranes are obtained from the chemical vapor deposition of a thin silica layer on a porous support. The theory is adapted from an existing classical statistical mechanics treatment for vitreous silica glasses. It is found that in the Nanosil membranes the permeation of CO, CO 2 and CH 4 is inhibited relatively to that of smaller sized species such as hydrogen and the lighter noble gases. Moreover, the latter show an unusual order of gas permeation, He > H 2 > D 2 > Ne, which does not depend on the size or mass of the diffusing species. The theoretical description is based on jumps of the permeating species between solubility sites in a solid matrix, and assumes equilibrium sorption in the sites, random motion, and a transition state with two degrees of vibrational freedom and one degree of translational freedom. The adapted form of the theoretical equation has a term to account for the loss of rotational degrees of freedom for polyatomic species and is applicable to molecules such as H 2 or D 2. Agreement between theoretical values and experimentally determined points indicate that the model equations are effective in describing the unusual behavior of hydrogen and the light noble gases. The higher permeation rate of He over H 2 or D 2 can be accounted for by the larger number of solubility sites that can accommodate the smaller sized He atoms. The lower permeation rate of Ne is due to its lower jump frequency when compared with the vibrational frequency of the other species. The density of solubility sites and the jump distance are important parameters in this analysis. The amorphous structure of silica is formed of 5-, 6-, 7- and 8-membered Si-O bonded rings and gives rise to solubility sites whose size is approximately 0.3 nm. The jump distance should have an inverse relationship with the number of solubility sites per unit volume, but so far this has not been calculated explicitly. In this work, we apply the Perkus-Yevick treatment to a collection of randomly-distributed, non-interacting sites embedded in a solid to clarify this relationship. Our analysis shows that the jump distances used in previous descriptions of vitreous glasses are smaller than the predictions from an array of points of zero volume, which is not possible. On the other hand, the jump distances in our membranes were calculated to be around 0.8 nm, which are physically realistic. The number of solubility sites (N s ∼ 10 26 m -3) was found to be smaller by about one order of magnitude than in vitreous glasses, while the vibrational frequencies, stayed relatively unchanged. The activation energies for permeation through the silica membrane were also smaller than the ones through glass and indicate the presence of a totally different structure. The Nanosil membrane is probably formed of larger Si-O rings which give rise to more open and less dense structures.

AB - The promising properties of silica-based H 2-selective membranes have resulted in extensive experimental studies, but these investigations have provided limited information about the mechanism of gas permeation through these membranes. In this work we present a theory of permeation that describes the transport and physical properties of silica-based membranes of the Nanosil type. Nanosil membranes are obtained from the chemical vapor deposition of a thin silica layer on a porous support. The theory is adapted from an existing classical statistical mechanics treatment for vitreous silica glasses. It is found that in the Nanosil membranes the permeation of CO, CO 2 and CH 4 is inhibited relatively to that of smaller sized species such as hydrogen and the lighter noble gases. Moreover, the latter show an unusual order of gas permeation, He > H 2 > D 2 > Ne, which does not depend on the size or mass of the diffusing species. The theoretical description is based on jumps of the permeating species between solubility sites in a solid matrix, and assumes equilibrium sorption in the sites, random motion, and a transition state with two degrees of vibrational freedom and one degree of translational freedom. The adapted form of the theoretical equation has a term to account for the loss of rotational degrees of freedom for polyatomic species and is applicable to molecules such as H 2 or D 2. Agreement between theoretical values and experimentally determined points indicate that the model equations are effective in describing the unusual behavior of hydrogen and the light noble gases. The higher permeation rate of He over H 2 or D 2 can be accounted for by the larger number of solubility sites that can accommodate the smaller sized He atoms. The lower permeation rate of Ne is due to its lower jump frequency when compared with the vibrational frequency of the other species. The density of solubility sites and the jump distance are important parameters in this analysis. The amorphous structure of silica is formed of 5-, 6-, 7- and 8-membered Si-O bonded rings and gives rise to solubility sites whose size is approximately 0.3 nm. The jump distance should have an inverse relationship with the number of solubility sites per unit volume, but so far this has not been calculated explicitly. In this work, we apply the Perkus-Yevick treatment to a collection of randomly-distributed, non-interacting sites embedded in a solid to clarify this relationship. Our analysis shows that the jump distances used in previous descriptions of vitreous glasses are smaller than the predictions from an array of points of zero volume, which is not possible. On the other hand, the jump distances in our membranes were calculated to be around 0.8 nm, which are physically realistic. The number of solubility sites (N s ∼ 10 26 m -3) was found to be smaller by about one order of magnitude than in vitreous glasses, while the vibrational frequencies, stayed relatively unchanged. The activation energies for permeation through the silica membrane were also smaller than the ones through glass and indicate the presence of a totally different structure. The Nanosil membrane is probably formed of larger Si-O rings which give rise to more open and less dense structures.

KW - Alumina

KW - Hydrogen permeability

KW - Percus-Yevick treatment

KW - Silica

KW - Solubility sites

KW - Statistical mechanics theory

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=7444243324&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=7444243324&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.memsci.2004.06.046

DO - 10.1016/j.memsci.2004.06.046

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:7444243324

VL - 244

SP - 45

EP - 53

JO - Jornal of Membrane Science

JF - Jornal of Membrane Science

SN - 0376-7388

IS - 1-2

ER -