Supercell refinement: A cautionary tale

Jeffrey Lovelace, Václav Petrícek, Garib Murshudov, Gloria E.O. Borgstahl

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Theoretically, crystals with supercells exist at a unique crossroads where they can be considered as either a large unit cell with closely spaced reflections in reciprocal space or a higher dimensional superspace with a modulation that is commensurate with the supercell. In the latter case, the structure would be defined as an average structure with functions representing a modulation to determine the atomic location in 3D space. Here, a model protein structure and simulated diffraction data were used to investigate the possibility of solving a real incommensurately modulated protein crystal using a supercell approximation. In this way, the answer was known and the refinement method could be tested. Firstly, an average structure was solved by using the 'main' reflections, which represent the subset of the reflections that belong to the subcell and in general are more intense than the 'satellite' reflections. The average structure was then expanded to create a supercell and refined using all of the reflections. Surprisingly, the refined solution did not match the expected solution, even though the statistics were excellent. Interestingly, the corresponding superspace group had multiple 3D daughter supercell space groups as possibilities, and it was one of the alternate daughter space groups that the refinement locked in on. The lessons learned here will be applied to a real incommensurately modulated profilin-actin crystal that has the same superspace group.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)852-860
Number of pages9
JournalActa Crystallographica Section D: Structural Biology
Volume75
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2019

Fingerprint

Profilins
Actins
Proteins

Keywords

  • aperiodic crystallography
  • modulated protein crystals
  • supercell crystallographic refinement
  • superspace group

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Structural Biology

Cite this

Supercell refinement : A cautionary tale. / Lovelace, Jeffrey; Petrícek, Václav; Murshudov, Garib; Borgstahl, Gloria E.O.

In: Acta Crystallographica Section D: Structural Biology, Vol. 75, 01.09.2019, p. 852-860.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lovelace, Jeffrey ; Petrícek, Václav ; Murshudov, Garib ; Borgstahl, Gloria E.O. / Supercell refinement : A cautionary tale. In: Acta Crystallographica Section D: Structural Biology. 2019 ; Vol. 75. pp. 852-860.
@article{638a4f181f49461aa02a223955de36d0,
title = "Supercell refinement: A cautionary tale",
abstract = "Theoretically, crystals with supercells exist at a unique crossroads where they can be considered as either a large unit cell with closely spaced reflections in reciprocal space or a higher dimensional superspace with a modulation that is commensurate with the supercell. In the latter case, the structure would be defined as an average structure with functions representing a modulation to determine the atomic location in 3D space. Here, a model protein structure and simulated diffraction data were used to investigate the possibility of solving a real incommensurately modulated protein crystal using a supercell approximation. In this way, the answer was known and the refinement method could be tested. Firstly, an average structure was solved by using the 'main' reflections, which represent the subset of the reflections that belong to the subcell and in general are more intense than the 'satellite' reflections. The average structure was then expanded to create a supercell and refined using all of the reflections. Surprisingly, the refined solution did not match the expected solution, even though the statistics were excellent. Interestingly, the corresponding superspace group had multiple 3D daughter supercell space groups as possibilities, and it was one of the alternate daughter space groups that the refinement locked in on. The lessons learned here will be applied to a real incommensurately modulated profilin-actin crystal that has the same superspace group.",
keywords = "aperiodic crystallography, modulated protein crystals, supercell crystallographic refinement, superspace group",
author = "Jeffrey Lovelace and V{\'a}clav Petr{\'i}cek and Garib Murshudov and Borgstahl, {Gloria E.O.}",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1107/S2059798319011082",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "75",
pages = "852--860",
journal = "Acta Crystallographica Section D: Structural Biology",
issn = "0907-4449",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Supercell refinement

T2 - A cautionary tale

AU - Lovelace, Jeffrey

AU - Petrícek, Václav

AU - Murshudov, Garib

AU - Borgstahl, Gloria E.O.

PY - 2019/9/1

Y1 - 2019/9/1

N2 - Theoretically, crystals with supercells exist at a unique crossroads where they can be considered as either a large unit cell with closely spaced reflections in reciprocal space or a higher dimensional superspace with a modulation that is commensurate with the supercell. In the latter case, the structure would be defined as an average structure with functions representing a modulation to determine the atomic location in 3D space. Here, a model protein structure and simulated diffraction data were used to investigate the possibility of solving a real incommensurately modulated protein crystal using a supercell approximation. In this way, the answer was known and the refinement method could be tested. Firstly, an average structure was solved by using the 'main' reflections, which represent the subset of the reflections that belong to the subcell and in general are more intense than the 'satellite' reflections. The average structure was then expanded to create a supercell and refined using all of the reflections. Surprisingly, the refined solution did not match the expected solution, even though the statistics were excellent. Interestingly, the corresponding superspace group had multiple 3D daughter supercell space groups as possibilities, and it was one of the alternate daughter space groups that the refinement locked in on. The lessons learned here will be applied to a real incommensurately modulated profilin-actin crystal that has the same superspace group.

AB - Theoretically, crystals with supercells exist at a unique crossroads where they can be considered as either a large unit cell with closely spaced reflections in reciprocal space or a higher dimensional superspace with a modulation that is commensurate with the supercell. In the latter case, the structure would be defined as an average structure with functions representing a modulation to determine the atomic location in 3D space. Here, a model protein structure and simulated diffraction data were used to investigate the possibility of solving a real incommensurately modulated protein crystal using a supercell approximation. In this way, the answer was known and the refinement method could be tested. Firstly, an average structure was solved by using the 'main' reflections, which represent the subset of the reflections that belong to the subcell and in general are more intense than the 'satellite' reflections. The average structure was then expanded to create a supercell and refined using all of the reflections. Surprisingly, the refined solution did not match the expected solution, even though the statistics were excellent. Interestingly, the corresponding superspace group had multiple 3D daughter supercell space groups as possibilities, and it was one of the alternate daughter space groups that the refinement locked in on. The lessons learned here will be applied to a real incommensurately modulated profilin-actin crystal that has the same superspace group.

KW - aperiodic crystallography

KW - modulated protein crystals

KW - supercell crystallographic refinement

KW - superspace group

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85071751621&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85071751621&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1107/S2059798319011082

DO - 10.1107/S2059798319011082

M3 - Article

C2 - 31478908

AN - SCOPUS:85071751621

VL - 75

SP - 852

EP - 860

JO - Acta Crystallographica Section D: Structural Biology

JF - Acta Crystallographica Section D: Structural Biology

SN - 0907-4449

ER -