Reproducibility and validity of bioimpedance spectroscopy for tracking changes in total body water

Implications for repeated measurements

Jordan R. Moon, Jeffrey R. Stout, Abbie E. Smith, Sarah E. Tobkin, Christopher M. Lockwood, Kristina L. Kendall, Jennifer L. Graef, David H. Fukuda, Pablo B. Costa, Matt S. Stock, Kaelin C. Young, Patrick S. Tucker, Eonho Kim, Trent J. Herda, Ashley A. Walter, Steven L. Ferguson, Vanessa D. Sherk, Joel T Cramer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Bioimpedance spectroscopy (BIS) has been used to track changes in total body water (TBW). Accurate TBW estimations can be influenced by both methodological and biological factors. One methodological variation that contributes to BIS TBW errors is the electrode placement. The purpose of the present study was to compare the reproducibility and validity of fixed-distance electrode placements (5cm) with the standard single-site electrode placements. Twenty-nine subjects (fifteen men and fourteen women) participated in the reproducibility study, while sixty-nine subjects (thirty-three men and thirty-six women) participated in the validity study. The reproducibility study included two measurements that were taken 24h apart, while the validity study consisted of a 12-week exercise intervention with measurements taken at weeks 1 and 12. TBW was estimated using BIS and 2H techniques. Reproducibility results indicated that fixed-distance electrodes reduced the day-to-day standard error of the measurement in men (from 113 to 081litres) but not in women (047litres). sem values were lower for women than for men, suggesting that BIS TBW estimates are sex dependent. Validity results produced similar accurate findings (mean difference<021litres). However, fixed-distance electrodes improved delta TBW errors (mean difference improvements>004litres in men, women, and men and women combined). When tracking changes in TBW, fixed-distance electrodes may reduce reproducibility errors and allow for smaller changes to be detected. However, the reduction of reproducibility errors may be greater for men than for women. Therefore, reproducibility calculations should be based on the sex of the sample population.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1384-1394
Number of pages11
JournalBritish Journal of Nutrition
Volume104
Issue number9
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 14 2010

Fingerprint

Body Water
Spectrum Analysis
Electrodes
Reproducibility of Results
Biological Factors
Exercise
Population

Keywords

  • Bioimpedance spectroscopy
  • Body composition
  • Electrode placement
  • Exercise intervention
  • H technique
  • Reproducibility

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine (miscellaneous)
  • Nutrition and Dietetics

Cite this

Reproducibility and validity of bioimpedance spectroscopy for tracking changes in total body water : Implications for repeated measurements. / Moon, Jordan R.; Stout, Jeffrey R.; Smith, Abbie E.; Tobkin, Sarah E.; Lockwood, Christopher M.; Kendall, Kristina L.; Graef, Jennifer L.; Fukuda, David H.; Costa, Pablo B.; Stock, Matt S.; Young, Kaelin C.; Tucker, Patrick S.; Kim, Eonho; Herda, Trent J.; Walter, Ashley A.; Ferguson, Steven L.; Sherk, Vanessa D.; Cramer, Joel T.

In: British Journal of Nutrition, Vol. 104, No. 9, 14.11.2010, p. 1384-1394.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Moon, JR, Stout, JR, Smith, AE, Tobkin, SE, Lockwood, CM, Kendall, KL, Graef, JL, Fukuda, DH, Costa, PB, Stock, MS, Young, KC, Tucker, PS, Kim, E, Herda, TJ, Walter, AA, Ferguson, SL, Sherk, VD & Cramer, JT 2010, 'Reproducibility and validity of bioimpedance spectroscopy for tracking changes in total body water: Implications for repeated measurements', British Journal of Nutrition, vol. 104, no. 9, pp. 1384-1394. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007114510002254
Moon, Jordan R. ; Stout, Jeffrey R. ; Smith, Abbie E. ; Tobkin, Sarah E. ; Lockwood, Christopher M. ; Kendall, Kristina L. ; Graef, Jennifer L. ; Fukuda, David H. ; Costa, Pablo B. ; Stock, Matt S. ; Young, Kaelin C. ; Tucker, Patrick S. ; Kim, Eonho ; Herda, Trent J. ; Walter, Ashley A. ; Ferguson, Steven L. ; Sherk, Vanessa D. ; Cramer, Joel T. / Reproducibility and validity of bioimpedance spectroscopy for tracking changes in total body water : Implications for repeated measurements. In: British Journal of Nutrition. 2010 ; Vol. 104, No. 9. pp. 1384-1394.
@article{e40ad4e8539240bfb9e3a9a1acd01c03,
title = "Reproducibility and validity of bioimpedance spectroscopy for tracking changes in total body water: Implications for repeated measurements",
abstract = "Bioimpedance spectroscopy (BIS) has been used to track changes in total body water (TBW). Accurate TBW estimations can be influenced by both methodological and biological factors. One methodological variation that contributes to BIS TBW errors is the electrode placement. The purpose of the present study was to compare the reproducibility and validity of fixed-distance electrode placements (5cm) with the standard single-site electrode placements. Twenty-nine subjects (fifteen men and fourteen women) participated in the reproducibility study, while sixty-nine subjects (thirty-three men and thirty-six women) participated in the validity study. The reproducibility study included two measurements that were taken 24h apart, while the validity study consisted of a 12-week exercise intervention with measurements taken at weeks 1 and 12. TBW was estimated using BIS and 2H techniques. Reproducibility results indicated that fixed-distance electrodes reduced the day-to-day standard error of the measurement in men (from 113 to 081litres) but not in women (047litres). sem values were lower for women than for men, suggesting that BIS TBW estimates are sex dependent. Validity results produced similar accurate findings (mean difference<021litres). However, fixed-distance electrodes improved delta TBW errors (mean difference improvements>004litres in men, women, and men and women combined). When tracking changes in TBW, fixed-distance electrodes may reduce reproducibility errors and allow for smaller changes to be detected. However, the reduction of reproducibility errors may be greater for men than for women. Therefore, reproducibility calculations should be based on the sex of the sample population.",
keywords = "Bioimpedance spectroscopy, Body composition, Electrode placement, Exercise intervention, H technique, Reproducibility",
author = "Moon, {Jordan R.} and Stout, {Jeffrey R.} and Smith, {Abbie E.} and Tobkin, {Sarah E.} and Lockwood, {Christopher M.} and Kendall, {Kristina L.} and Graef, {Jennifer L.} and Fukuda, {David H.} and Costa, {Pablo B.} and Stock, {Matt S.} and Young, {Kaelin C.} and Tucker, {Patrick S.} and Eonho Kim and Herda, {Trent J.} and Walter, {Ashley A.} and Ferguson, {Steven L.} and Sherk, {Vanessa D.} and Cramer, {Joel T}",
year = "2010",
month = "11",
day = "14",
doi = "10.1017/S0007114510002254",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "104",
pages = "1384--1394",
journal = "British Journal of Nutrition",
issn = "0007-1145",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reproducibility and validity of bioimpedance spectroscopy for tracking changes in total body water

T2 - Implications for repeated measurements

AU - Moon, Jordan R.

AU - Stout, Jeffrey R.

AU - Smith, Abbie E.

AU - Tobkin, Sarah E.

AU - Lockwood, Christopher M.

AU - Kendall, Kristina L.

AU - Graef, Jennifer L.

AU - Fukuda, David H.

AU - Costa, Pablo B.

AU - Stock, Matt S.

AU - Young, Kaelin C.

AU - Tucker, Patrick S.

AU - Kim, Eonho

AU - Herda, Trent J.

AU - Walter, Ashley A.

AU - Ferguson, Steven L.

AU - Sherk, Vanessa D.

AU - Cramer, Joel T

PY - 2010/11/14

Y1 - 2010/11/14

N2 - Bioimpedance spectroscopy (BIS) has been used to track changes in total body water (TBW). Accurate TBW estimations can be influenced by both methodological and biological factors. One methodological variation that contributes to BIS TBW errors is the electrode placement. The purpose of the present study was to compare the reproducibility and validity of fixed-distance electrode placements (5cm) with the standard single-site electrode placements. Twenty-nine subjects (fifteen men and fourteen women) participated in the reproducibility study, while sixty-nine subjects (thirty-three men and thirty-six women) participated in the validity study. The reproducibility study included two measurements that were taken 24h apart, while the validity study consisted of a 12-week exercise intervention with measurements taken at weeks 1 and 12. TBW was estimated using BIS and 2H techniques. Reproducibility results indicated that fixed-distance electrodes reduced the day-to-day standard error of the measurement in men (from 113 to 081litres) but not in women (047litres). sem values were lower for women than for men, suggesting that BIS TBW estimates are sex dependent. Validity results produced similar accurate findings (mean difference<021litres). However, fixed-distance electrodes improved delta TBW errors (mean difference improvements>004litres in men, women, and men and women combined). When tracking changes in TBW, fixed-distance electrodes may reduce reproducibility errors and allow for smaller changes to be detected. However, the reduction of reproducibility errors may be greater for men than for women. Therefore, reproducibility calculations should be based on the sex of the sample population.

AB - Bioimpedance spectroscopy (BIS) has been used to track changes in total body water (TBW). Accurate TBW estimations can be influenced by both methodological and biological factors. One methodological variation that contributes to BIS TBW errors is the electrode placement. The purpose of the present study was to compare the reproducibility and validity of fixed-distance electrode placements (5cm) with the standard single-site electrode placements. Twenty-nine subjects (fifteen men and fourteen women) participated in the reproducibility study, while sixty-nine subjects (thirty-three men and thirty-six women) participated in the validity study. The reproducibility study included two measurements that were taken 24h apart, while the validity study consisted of a 12-week exercise intervention with measurements taken at weeks 1 and 12. TBW was estimated using BIS and 2H techniques. Reproducibility results indicated that fixed-distance electrodes reduced the day-to-day standard error of the measurement in men (from 113 to 081litres) but not in women (047litres). sem values were lower for women than for men, suggesting that BIS TBW estimates are sex dependent. Validity results produced similar accurate findings (mean difference<021litres). However, fixed-distance electrodes improved delta TBW errors (mean difference improvements>004litres in men, women, and men and women combined). When tracking changes in TBW, fixed-distance electrodes may reduce reproducibility errors and allow for smaller changes to be detected. However, the reduction of reproducibility errors may be greater for men than for women. Therefore, reproducibility calculations should be based on the sex of the sample population.

KW - Bioimpedance spectroscopy

KW - Body composition

KW - Electrode placement

KW - Exercise intervention

KW - H technique

KW - Reproducibility

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=78149487428&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=78149487428&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/S0007114510002254

DO - 10.1017/S0007114510002254

M3 - Article

VL - 104

SP - 1384

EP - 1394

JO - British Journal of Nutrition

JF - British Journal of Nutrition

SN - 0007-1145

IS - 9

ER -