Perceptual and instrumental assessments of orofacial muscle tone in dysarthric and normal speakers

Angela M. Dietsch, Nancy Pearl Solomon, Laura A. Sharkey, Joseph R. Duffy, Edythe A. Strand, Heather M. Clark

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Clinical assessment of orofacial muscle tone is of interest for differential diagnosis of the dysarthrias, but standardized procedures and normative data are lacking. In this study, perceptual ratings of tone were compared with instrumental measures of tissue stiffness for facial, lingual, and masticatory muscles in 70 individuals with dysarthria. Perceptual and instrumental tone data were discordant and failed to discriminate between five dysarthria types. These results raised concerns about the validity of Myoton-3 stiffness measures in the orofacial muscles. Therefore, a second study evaluated contracted and relaxed orofacial muscles in 10 neurotypical adults. Results for the cheek, masseter, and lateral tongue surface followed predictions, with significantly higher tissue stiffness during contraction. In contradiction, stiffness measures from the superior surface of the tongue were lower during contraction. Superior-to-inferior tongue thickness was notably increased during contraction. A third study revealed that tissue thickness up to ∼10 mm significantly affected Myoton-3 measures. Altered tissue thickness due to neuromuscular conditions like spasticity and atrophy may have undermined the detection of group differences in the original sample of dysarthric speakers. These experiments underscore the challenges of assessing orofacial muscle tone and identify considerations for quantification of tone-related differences across dysarthria groups in future studies.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1127-1142
Number of pages16
JournalJournal of Rehabilitation Research and Development
Volume51
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2014

Fingerprint

Dysarthria
Tongue
Muscles
Facial Muscles
Masticatory Muscles
Cheek
Atrophy
Differential Diagnosis

Keywords

  • Dysarthria
  • Motor speech assessment
  • Muscle tone
  • Myoton
  • Neurological disorders
  • Orofacial muscles
  • Rigidity
  • Spas-ticity
  • Stiffness
  • Tissue thickness
  • Tongue
  • Viscoelastic properties

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Rehabilitation

Cite this

Perceptual and instrumental assessments of orofacial muscle tone in dysarthric and normal speakers. / Dietsch, Angela M.; Solomon, Nancy Pearl; Sharkey, Laura A.; Duffy, Joseph R.; Strand, Edythe A.; Clark, Heather M.

In: Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development, Vol. 51, No. 7, 01.01.2014, p. 1127-1142.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dietsch, Angela M. ; Solomon, Nancy Pearl ; Sharkey, Laura A. ; Duffy, Joseph R. ; Strand, Edythe A. ; Clark, Heather M. / Perceptual and instrumental assessments of orofacial muscle tone in dysarthric and normal speakers. In: Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development. 2014 ; Vol. 51, No. 7. pp. 1127-1142.
@article{c27bb94279034602a9eb4ee984d16dd8,
title = "Perceptual and instrumental assessments of orofacial muscle tone in dysarthric and normal speakers",
abstract = "Clinical assessment of orofacial muscle tone is of interest for differential diagnosis of the dysarthrias, but standardized procedures and normative data are lacking. In this study, perceptual ratings of tone were compared with instrumental measures of tissue stiffness for facial, lingual, and masticatory muscles in 70 individuals with dysarthria. Perceptual and instrumental tone data were discordant and failed to discriminate between five dysarthria types. These results raised concerns about the validity of Myoton-3 stiffness measures in the orofacial muscles. Therefore, a second study evaluated contracted and relaxed orofacial muscles in 10 neurotypical adults. Results for the cheek, masseter, and lateral tongue surface followed predictions, with significantly higher tissue stiffness during contraction. In contradiction, stiffness measures from the superior surface of the tongue were lower during contraction. Superior-to-inferior tongue thickness was notably increased during contraction. A third study revealed that tissue thickness up to ∼10 mm significantly affected Myoton-3 measures. Altered tissue thickness due to neuromuscular conditions like spasticity and atrophy may have undermined the detection of group differences in the original sample of dysarthric speakers. These experiments underscore the challenges of assessing orofacial muscle tone and identify considerations for quantification of tone-related differences across dysarthria groups in future studies.",
keywords = "Dysarthria, Motor speech assessment, Muscle tone, Myoton, Neurological disorders, Orofacial muscles, Rigidity, Spas-ticity, Stiffness, Tissue thickness, Tongue, Viscoelastic properties",
author = "Dietsch, {Angela M.} and Solomon, {Nancy Pearl} and Sharkey, {Laura A.} and Duffy, {Joseph R.} and Strand, {Edythe A.} and Clark, {Heather M.}",
year = "2014",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1682/JRRD.2013.07.0167",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "51",
pages = "1127--1142",
journal = "Journal of rehabilitation R&D",
issn = "0748-7711",
publisher = "Rehabilitation Research and Development Service",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Perceptual and instrumental assessments of orofacial muscle tone in dysarthric and normal speakers

AU - Dietsch, Angela M.

AU - Solomon, Nancy Pearl

AU - Sharkey, Laura A.

AU - Duffy, Joseph R.

AU - Strand, Edythe A.

AU - Clark, Heather M.

PY - 2014/1/1

Y1 - 2014/1/1

N2 - Clinical assessment of orofacial muscle tone is of interest for differential diagnosis of the dysarthrias, but standardized procedures and normative data are lacking. In this study, perceptual ratings of tone were compared with instrumental measures of tissue stiffness for facial, lingual, and masticatory muscles in 70 individuals with dysarthria. Perceptual and instrumental tone data were discordant and failed to discriminate between five dysarthria types. These results raised concerns about the validity of Myoton-3 stiffness measures in the orofacial muscles. Therefore, a second study evaluated contracted and relaxed orofacial muscles in 10 neurotypical adults. Results for the cheek, masseter, and lateral tongue surface followed predictions, with significantly higher tissue stiffness during contraction. In contradiction, stiffness measures from the superior surface of the tongue were lower during contraction. Superior-to-inferior tongue thickness was notably increased during contraction. A third study revealed that tissue thickness up to ∼10 mm significantly affected Myoton-3 measures. Altered tissue thickness due to neuromuscular conditions like spasticity and atrophy may have undermined the detection of group differences in the original sample of dysarthric speakers. These experiments underscore the challenges of assessing orofacial muscle tone and identify considerations for quantification of tone-related differences across dysarthria groups in future studies.

AB - Clinical assessment of orofacial muscle tone is of interest for differential diagnosis of the dysarthrias, but standardized procedures and normative data are lacking. In this study, perceptual ratings of tone were compared with instrumental measures of tissue stiffness for facial, lingual, and masticatory muscles in 70 individuals with dysarthria. Perceptual and instrumental tone data were discordant and failed to discriminate between five dysarthria types. These results raised concerns about the validity of Myoton-3 stiffness measures in the orofacial muscles. Therefore, a second study evaluated contracted and relaxed orofacial muscles in 10 neurotypical adults. Results for the cheek, masseter, and lateral tongue surface followed predictions, with significantly higher tissue stiffness during contraction. In contradiction, stiffness measures from the superior surface of the tongue were lower during contraction. Superior-to-inferior tongue thickness was notably increased during contraction. A third study revealed that tissue thickness up to ∼10 mm significantly affected Myoton-3 measures. Altered tissue thickness due to neuromuscular conditions like spasticity and atrophy may have undermined the detection of group differences in the original sample of dysarthric speakers. These experiments underscore the challenges of assessing orofacial muscle tone and identify considerations for quantification of tone-related differences across dysarthria groups in future studies.

KW - Dysarthria

KW - Motor speech assessment

KW - Muscle tone

KW - Myoton

KW - Neurological disorders

KW - Orofacial muscles

KW - Rigidity

KW - Spas-ticity

KW - Stiffness

KW - Tissue thickness

KW - Tongue

KW - Viscoelastic properties

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84922861612&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84922861612&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1682/JRRD.2013.07.0167

DO - 10.1682/JRRD.2013.07.0167

M3 - Article

C2 - 25437151

AN - SCOPUS:84922861612

VL - 51

SP - 1127

EP - 1142

JO - Journal of rehabilitation R&D

JF - Journal of rehabilitation R&D

SN - 0748-7711

IS - 7

ER -