Justice League? Depictions of Justice in Children's Superhero Cartoons

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The literature argues that media depictions of criminal justice present messages that conform to and promote the dominant ideology about the crime problem and how to solve it. Research has focused on television news and adult programs, but little research has examined messages about justice present in children's shows. To fill this gap, an ethnographic content analysis of children's cartoons was conducted, using a sample of episodes from Batman: The Animated Series, Spider-Man, and Justice League Unlimited. Several themes emerged. First, the justice system is often depicted as ill equipped to handle serious crime. Second, story lines suggested that the justice system is relatively weak, plagued by corruption or ineffectiveness. Third, heroes are driven by their notions of justice, recognizing that only they can stop the worst criminals and are morally obligated to do so. Fourth, heroes are willing to use force to capture offenders, but they also use brain power. Finally, although heroes work largely outside the law, they are supportive of the efforts of honest justice system actors. In sum, these shows provide messages about justice that are consistent with and supportive of the dominant ideology that derides rehabilitation and emphasizes incapacitation. They are also congruent with messages, images, and frames presented in adult-oriented media. By drawing on moral elements and the problem frame, they act as cultural primers by which young people may interpret subsequent imagery of crime and justice. The consistency across genres contributes to the social reality of crime and control.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)50-69
Number of pages20
JournalCriminal Justice Review
Volume38
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 8 2013

Fingerprint

cartoon
justice
offense
ideology
present
social reality
corruption
rehabilitation
offender
television
genre
content analysis
brain
news
Law

Keywords

  • cartoons
  • cultural criminology
  • media and crime
  • media and justice
  • superheroes

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Law

Cite this

Justice League? Depictions of Justice in Children's Superhero Cartoons. / Kort-Butler, Lisa A.

In: Criminal Justice Review, Vol. 38, No. 1, 08.03.2013, p. 50-69.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{45aa2b61790047cf937a01be55db083c,
title = "Justice League?: Depictions of Justice in Children's Superhero Cartoons",
abstract = "The literature argues that media depictions of criminal justice present messages that conform to and promote the dominant ideology about the crime problem and how to solve it. Research has focused on television news and adult programs, but little research has examined messages about justice present in children's shows. To fill this gap, an ethnographic content analysis of children's cartoons was conducted, using a sample of episodes from Batman: The Animated Series, Spider-Man, and Justice League Unlimited. Several themes emerged. First, the justice system is often depicted as ill equipped to handle serious crime. Second, story lines suggested that the justice system is relatively weak, plagued by corruption or ineffectiveness. Third, heroes are driven by their notions of justice, recognizing that only they can stop the worst criminals and are morally obligated to do so. Fourth, heroes are willing to use force to capture offenders, but they also use brain power. Finally, although heroes work largely outside the law, they are supportive of the efforts of honest justice system actors. In sum, these shows provide messages about justice that are consistent with and supportive of the dominant ideology that derides rehabilitation and emphasizes incapacitation. They are also congruent with messages, images, and frames presented in adult-oriented media. By drawing on moral elements and the problem frame, they act as cultural primers by which young people may interpret subsequent imagery of crime and justice. The consistency across genres contributes to the social reality of crime and control.",
keywords = "cartoons, cultural criminology, media and crime, media and justice, superheroes",
author = "Kort-Butler, {Lisa A}",
year = "2013",
month = "3",
day = "8",
doi = "10.1177/0734016812467201",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "38",
pages = "50--69",
journal = "Criminal Justice Review",
issn = "0734-0168",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Justice League?

T2 - Depictions of Justice in Children's Superhero Cartoons

AU - Kort-Butler, Lisa A

PY - 2013/3/8

Y1 - 2013/3/8

N2 - The literature argues that media depictions of criminal justice present messages that conform to and promote the dominant ideology about the crime problem and how to solve it. Research has focused on television news and adult programs, but little research has examined messages about justice present in children's shows. To fill this gap, an ethnographic content analysis of children's cartoons was conducted, using a sample of episodes from Batman: The Animated Series, Spider-Man, and Justice League Unlimited. Several themes emerged. First, the justice system is often depicted as ill equipped to handle serious crime. Second, story lines suggested that the justice system is relatively weak, plagued by corruption or ineffectiveness. Third, heroes are driven by their notions of justice, recognizing that only they can stop the worst criminals and are morally obligated to do so. Fourth, heroes are willing to use force to capture offenders, but they also use brain power. Finally, although heroes work largely outside the law, they are supportive of the efforts of honest justice system actors. In sum, these shows provide messages about justice that are consistent with and supportive of the dominant ideology that derides rehabilitation and emphasizes incapacitation. They are also congruent with messages, images, and frames presented in adult-oriented media. By drawing on moral elements and the problem frame, they act as cultural primers by which young people may interpret subsequent imagery of crime and justice. The consistency across genres contributes to the social reality of crime and control.

AB - The literature argues that media depictions of criminal justice present messages that conform to and promote the dominant ideology about the crime problem and how to solve it. Research has focused on television news and adult programs, but little research has examined messages about justice present in children's shows. To fill this gap, an ethnographic content analysis of children's cartoons was conducted, using a sample of episodes from Batman: The Animated Series, Spider-Man, and Justice League Unlimited. Several themes emerged. First, the justice system is often depicted as ill equipped to handle serious crime. Second, story lines suggested that the justice system is relatively weak, plagued by corruption or ineffectiveness. Third, heroes are driven by their notions of justice, recognizing that only they can stop the worst criminals and are morally obligated to do so. Fourth, heroes are willing to use force to capture offenders, but they also use brain power. Finally, although heroes work largely outside the law, they are supportive of the efforts of honest justice system actors. In sum, these shows provide messages about justice that are consistent with and supportive of the dominant ideology that derides rehabilitation and emphasizes incapacitation. They are also congruent with messages, images, and frames presented in adult-oriented media. By drawing on moral elements and the problem frame, they act as cultural primers by which young people may interpret subsequent imagery of crime and justice. The consistency across genres contributes to the social reality of crime and control.

KW - cartoons

KW - cultural criminology

KW - media and crime

KW - media and justice

KW - superheroes

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84874569692&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84874569692&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0734016812467201

DO - 10.1177/0734016812467201

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84874569692

VL - 38

SP - 50

EP - 69

JO - Criminal Justice Review

JF - Criminal Justice Review

SN - 0734-0168

IS - 1

ER -