Is match ethics an oxymoron?

Kimberly D. Anderson, Donald M. Jacobs, Amy V. Blue

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Graduate medical education has undergone economic and structural changes - changes that have placed increasing pressure on medical students and programs to match effectively. This study documents the experiences, perceptions, and ethical dilemmas of medical students with the 1998 match process. METHODS: Surveyed were 437 senior students from three medical schools. Students were questioned about: interviewing practices, communication with programs, commitments made, ethical dilemmas faced, and the match process itself. Data were analyzed using Student's t test, the chi- square test, and descriptive statistics. RESULTS: In all, 314 (72%) students responded. Programs expect postinterview communication from students (57%). Students perceive that programs are making 'informal' commitments (43%), lying to them (33%), and encouraging their unethical behavior in order to match (21%). Ethical dilemmas are related to requests for informal commitments. CONCLUSIONS: The NRMP's ruling that denounces prematch commitments is being broken by students and programs alike, resulting in the promotion of unprofessional behavior and gamesmanship.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)237-239
Number of pages3
JournalAmerican journal of surgery
Volume177
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 1999

Fingerprint

Ethics
Students
Medical Students
Professional Misconduct
Communication
Graduate Medical Education
Chi-Square Distribution
Medical Schools
Economics
Pressure

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Is match ethics an oxymoron? / Anderson, Kimberly D.; Jacobs, Donald M.; Blue, Amy V.

In: American journal of surgery, Vol. 177, No. 3, 01.03.1999, p. 237-239.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Anderson, Kimberly D. ; Jacobs, Donald M. ; Blue, Amy V. / Is match ethics an oxymoron?. In: American journal of surgery. 1999 ; Vol. 177, No. 3. pp. 237-239.
@article{c110c2f8218f4da394ea0ae54b675ced,
title = "Is match ethics an oxymoron?",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Graduate medical education has undergone economic and structural changes - changes that have placed increasing pressure on medical students and programs to match effectively. This study documents the experiences, perceptions, and ethical dilemmas of medical students with the 1998 match process. METHODS: Surveyed were 437 senior students from three medical schools. Students were questioned about: interviewing practices, communication with programs, commitments made, ethical dilemmas faced, and the match process itself. Data were analyzed using Student's t test, the chi- square test, and descriptive statistics. RESULTS: In all, 314 (72{\%}) students responded. Programs expect postinterview communication from students (57{\%}). Students perceive that programs are making 'informal' commitments (43{\%}), lying to them (33{\%}), and encouraging their unethical behavior in order to match (21{\%}). Ethical dilemmas are related to requests for informal commitments. CONCLUSIONS: The NRMP's ruling that denounces prematch commitments is being broken by students and programs alike, resulting in the promotion of unprofessional behavior and gamesmanship.",
author = "Anderson, {Kimberly D.} and Jacobs, {Donald M.} and Blue, {Amy V.}",
year = "1999",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/S0002-9610(99)00019-7",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "177",
pages = "237--239",
journal = "American Journal of Surgery",
issn = "0002-9610",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Is match ethics an oxymoron?

AU - Anderson, Kimberly D.

AU - Jacobs, Donald M.

AU - Blue, Amy V.

PY - 1999/3/1

Y1 - 1999/3/1

N2 - BACKGROUND: Graduate medical education has undergone economic and structural changes - changes that have placed increasing pressure on medical students and programs to match effectively. This study documents the experiences, perceptions, and ethical dilemmas of medical students with the 1998 match process. METHODS: Surveyed were 437 senior students from three medical schools. Students were questioned about: interviewing practices, communication with programs, commitments made, ethical dilemmas faced, and the match process itself. Data were analyzed using Student's t test, the chi- square test, and descriptive statistics. RESULTS: In all, 314 (72%) students responded. Programs expect postinterview communication from students (57%). Students perceive that programs are making 'informal' commitments (43%), lying to them (33%), and encouraging their unethical behavior in order to match (21%). Ethical dilemmas are related to requests for informal commitments. CONCLUSIONS: The NRMP's ruling that denounces prematch commitments is being broken by students and programs alike, resulting in the promotion of unprofessional behavior and gamesmanship.

AB - BACKGROUND: Graduate medical education has undergone economic and structural changes - changes that have placed increasing pressure on medical students and programs to match effectively. This study documents the experiences, perceptions, and ethical dilemmas of medical students with the 1998 match process. METHODS: Surveyed were 437 senior students from three medical schools. Students were questioned about: interviewing practices, communication with programs, commitments made, ethical dilemmas faced, and the match process itself. Data were analyzed using Student's t test, the chi- square test, and descriptive statistics. RESULTS: In all, 314 (72%) students responded. Programs expect postinterview communication from students (57%). Students perceive that programs are making 'informal' commitments (43%), lying to them (33%), and encouraging their unethical behavior in order to match (21%). Ethical dilemmas are related to requests for informal commitments. CONCLUSIONS: The NRMP's ruling that denounces prematch commitments is being broken by students and programs alike, resulting in the promotion of unprofessional behavior and gamesmanship.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0032911323&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0032911323&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/S0002-9610(99)00019-7

DO - 10.1016/S0002-9610(99)00019-7

M3 - Article

C2 - 10219861

AN - SCOPUS:0032911323

VL - 177

SP - 237

EP - 239

JO - American Journal of Surgery

JF - American Journal of Surgery

SN - 0002-9610

IS - 3

ER -