Including phenotypic causal networks in genome-wide association studies using mixed effects structural equation models

Mehdi Momen, Ahmad Ayatollahi Mehrgardi, Mahmoud Amiri Roudbar, Andreas Kranis, Renan Mercuri Pinto, Bruno D. Valente, Gota Morota, Guilherme J.M. Rosa, Daniel Gianola

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Network based statistical models accounting for putative causal relationships among multiple phenotypes can be used to infer single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) effect which transmitting through a given causal path in genome-wide association studies (GWAS). In GWAS with multiple phenotypes, reconstructing underlying causal structures among traits and SNPs using a single statistical framework is essential for understanding the entirety of genotype-phenotype maps. A structural equation model (SEM) can be used for such purposes. We applied SEM to GWAS (SEM-GWAS) in chickens, taking into account putative causal relationships among breast meat (BM), body weight (BW), hen-house production (HHP), and SNPs. We assessed the performance of SEM-GWAS by comparing the model results with those obtained from traditional multi-trait association analyses (MTM-GWAS). Three different putative causal path diagrams were inferred from highest posterior density (HPD) intervals of 0.75, 0.85, and 0.95 using the inductive causation algorithm. A positive path coefficient was estimated for BM → BW, and negative values were obtained for BM → HHP and BW → HHP in all implemented scenarios. Further, the application of SEM-GWAS enabled the decomposition of SNP effects into direct, indirect, and total effects, identifying whether a SNP effect is acting directly or indirectly on a given trait. In contrast, MTM-GWAS only captured overall genetic effects on traits, which is equivalent to combining the direct and indirect SNP effects from SEM-GWAS. Although MTM-GWAS and SEM-GWAS use the similar probabilistic models, we provide evidence that SEM-GWAS captures complex relationships in terms of causal meaning and mediation and delivers a more comprehensive understanding of SNP effects compared to MTM-GWAS. Our results showed that SEM-GWAS provides important insight regarding the mechanism by which identified SNPs control traits by partitioning them into direct, indirect, and total SNP effects.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number455
JournalFrontiers in Genetics
Volume9
Issue numberOCT
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 9 2018

Fingerprint

Genome-Wide Association Study
Structural Models
Single Nucleotide Polymorphism
Meat
Breast
Body Weight
Statistical Models
Phenotype
Causality
Chickens
Genotype

Keywords

  • Causal structure
  • GWAS
  • Multiple traits
  • Path analysis
  • SEM
  • SNP effect

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Molecular Medicine
  • Genetics
  • Genetics(clinical)

Cite this

Momen, M., Mehrgardi, A. A., Roudbar, M. A., Kranis, A., Pinto, R. M., Valente, B. D., ... Gianola, D. (2018). Including phenotypic causal networks in genome-wide association studies using mixed effects structural equation models. Frontiers in Genetics, 9(OCT), [455]. https://doi.org/10.3389/fgene.2018.00455

Including phenotypic causal networks in genome-wide association studies using mixed effects structural equation models. / Momen, Mehdi; Mehrgardi, Ahmad Ayatollahi; Roudbar, Mahmoud Amiri; Kranis, Andreas; Pinto, Renan Mercuri; Valente, Bruno D.; Morota, Gota; Rosa, Guilherme J.M.; Gianola, Daniel.

In: Frontiers in Genetics, Vol. 9, No. OCT, 455, 09.10.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Momen, M, Mehrgardi, AA, Roudbar, MA, Kranis, A, Pinto, RM, Valente, BD, Morota, G, Rosa, GJM & Gianola, D 2018, 'Including phenotypic causal networks in genome-wide association studies using mixed effects structural equation models', Frontiers in Genetics, vol. 9, no. OCT, 455. https://doi.org/10.3389/fgene.2018.00455
Momen, Mehdi ; Mehrgardi, Ahmad Ayatollahi ; Roudbar, Mahmoud Amiri ; Kranis, Andreas ; Pinto, Renan Mercuri ; Valente, Bruno D. ; Morota, Gota ; Rosa, Guilherme J.M. ; Gianola, Daniel. / Including phenotypic causal networks in genome-wide association studies using mixed effects structural equation models. In: Frontiers in Genetics. 2018 ; Vol. 9, No. OCT.
@article{fb1f310276fe47418781dc7594b05fea,
title = "Including phenotypic causal networks in genome-wide association studies using mixed effects structural equation models",
abstract = "Network based statistical models accounting for putative causal relationships among multiple phenotypes can be used to infer single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) effect which transmitting through a given causal path in genome-wide association studies (GWAS). In GWAS with multiple phenotypes, reconstructing underlying causal structures among traits and SNPs using a single statistical framework is essential for understanding the entirety of genotype-phenotype maps. A structural equation model (SEM) can be used for such purposes. We applied SEM to GWAS (SEM-GWAS) in chickens, taking into account putative causal relationships among breast meat (BM), body weight (BW), hen-house production (HHP), and SNPs. We assessed the performance of SEM-GWAS by comparing the model results with those obtained from traditional multi-trait association analyses (MTM-GWAS). Three different putative causal path diagrams were inferred from highest posterior density (HPD) intervals of 0.75, 0.85, and 0.95 using the inductive causation algorithm. A positive path coefficient was estimated for BM → BW, and negative values were obtained for BM → HHP and BW → HHP in all implemented scenarios. Further, the application of SEM-GWAS enabled the decomposition of SNP effects into direct, indirect, and total effects, identifying whether a SNP effect is acting directly or indirectly on a given trait. In contrast, MTM-GWAS only captured overall genetic effects on traits, which is equivalent to combining the direct and indirect SNP effects from SEM-GWAS. Although MTM-GWAS and SEM-GWAS use the similar probabilistic models, we provide evidence that SEM-GWAS captures complex relationships in terms of causal meaning and mediation and delivers a more comprehensive understanding of SNP effects compared to MTM-GWAS. Our results showed that SEM-GWAS provides important insight regarding the mechanism by which identified SNPs control traits by partitioning them into direct, indirect, and total SNP effects.",
keywords = "Causal structure, GWAS, Multiple traits, Path analysis, SEM, SNP effect",
author = "Mehdi Momen and Mehrgardi, {Ahmad Ayatollahi} and Roudbar, {Mahmoud Amiri} and Andreas Kranis and Pinto, {Renan Mercuri} and Valente, {Bruno D.} and Gota Morota and Rosa, {Guilherme J.M.} and Daniel Gianola",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "9",
doi = "10.3389/fgene.2018.00455",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "9",
journal = "Frontiers in Genetics",
issn = "1664-8021",
publisher = "Frontiers Media S. A.",
number = "OCT",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Including phenotypic causal networks in genome-wide association studies using mixed effects structural equation models

AU - Momen, Mehdi

AU - Mehrgardi, Ahmad Ayatollahi

AU - Roudbar, Mahmoud Amiri

AU - Kranis, Andreas

AU - Pinto, Renan Mercuri

AU - Valente, Bruno D.

AU - Morota, Gota

AU - Rosa, Guilherme J.M.

AU - Gianola, Daniel

PY - 2018/10/9

Y1 - 2018/10/9

N2 - Network based statistical models accounting for putative causal relationships among multiple phenotypes can be used to infer single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) effect which transmitting through a given causal path in genome-wide association studies (GWAS). In GWAS with multiple phenotypes, reconstructing underlying causal structures among traits and SNPs using a single statistical framework is essential for understanding the entirety of genotype-phenotype maps. A structural equation model (SEM) can be used for such purposes. We applied SEM to GWAS (SEM-GWAS) in chickens, taking into account putative causal relationships among breast meat (BM), body weight (BW), hen-house production (HHP), and SNPs. We assessed the performance of SEM-GWAS by comparing the model results with those obtained from traditional multi-trait association analyses (MTM-GWAS). Three different putative causal path diagrams were inferred from highest posterior density (HPD) intervals of 0.75, 0.85, and 0.95 using the inductive causation algorithm. A positive path coefficient was estimated for BM → BW, and negative values were obtained for BM → HHP and BW → HHP in all implemented scenarios. Further, the application of SEM-GWAS enabled the decomposition of SNP effects into direct, indirect, and total effects, identifying whether a SNP effect is acting directly or indirectly on a given trait. In contrast, MTM-GWAS only captured overall genetic effects on traits, which is equivalent to combining the direct and indirect SNP effects from SEM-GWAS. Although MTM-GWAS and SEM-GWAS use the similar probabilistic models, we provide evidence that SEM-GWAS captures complex relationships in terms of causal meaning and mediation and delivers a more comprehensive understanding of SNP effects compared to MTM-GWAS. Our results showed that SEM-GWAS provides important insight regarding the mechanism by which identified SNPs control traits by partitioning them into direct, indirect, and total SNP effects.

AB - Network based statistical models accounting for putative causal relationships among multiple phenotypes can be used to infer single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) effect which transmitting through a given causal path in genome-wide association studies (GWAS). In GWAS with multiple phenotypes, reconstructing underlying causal structures among traits and SNPs using a single statistical framework is essential for understanding the entirety of genotype-phenotype maps. A structural equation model (SEM) can be used for such purposes. We applied SEM to GWAS (SEM-GWAS) in chickens, taking into account putative causal relationships among breast meat (BM), body weight (BW), hen-house production (HHP), and SNPs. We assessed the performance of SEM-GWAS by comparing the model results with those obtained from traditional multi-trait association analyses (MTM-GWAS). Three different putative causal path diagrams were inferred from highest posterior density (HPD) intervals of 0.75, 0.85, and 0.95 using the inductive causation algorithm. A positive path coefficient was estimated for BM → BW, and negative values were obtained for BM → HHP and BW → HHP in all implemented scenarios. Further, the application of SEM-GWAS enabled the decomposition of SNP effects into direct, indirect, and total effects, identifying whether a SNP effect is acting directly or indirectly on a given trait. In contrast, MTM-GWAS only captured overall genetic effects on traits, which is equivalent to combining the direct and indirect SNP effects from SEM-GWAS. Although MTM-GWAS and SEM-GWAS use the similar probabilistic models, we provide evidence that SEM-GWAS captures complex relationships in terms of causal meaning and mediation and delivers a more comprehensive understanding of SNP effects compared to MTM-GWAS. Our results showed that SEM-GWAS provides important insight regarding the mechanism by which identified SNPs control traits by partitioning them into direct, indirect, and total SNP effects.

KW - Causal structure

KW - GWAS

KW - Multiple traits

KW - Path analysis

KW - SEM

KW - SNP effect

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85055349939&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85055349939&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3389/fgene.2018.00455

DO - 10.3389/fgene.2018.00455

M3 - Article

C2 - 30356716

AN - SCOPUS:85055349939

VL - 9

JO - Frontiers in Genetics

JF - Frontiers in Genetics

SN - 1664-8021

IS - OCT

M1 - 455

ER -