Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation

Alexandra L. Quittner, David H. Barker, Carolyn Snell, Ivette Cruz, Lynda Grace Mcdonald, Mary E. Grimley, Melissa Botteri, Kristen Marciel, Laurie Eisenberg, William Luxford, Karen Johnson, Amy Martinez, Jean Des-Jardin, Leslie Visser-Dumont, Sophie E Ambrose, Carren Stika, Melinda Gillinger, John Niparko, Jill Chinnici, Howard Francis & 34 others Steve Bowditch, Jennifer Yeagle, Courtney Carver, Andrea Marlowe, Andrea Gregg, Jennifer Gross, Rick Ostrander, Nancy Mellon, Jennifer Mertes, Mary O'Leary Kane, Annelle Hodges, Thomas Balkany, Alina Lopez, Leslie Goodwin, Teresa Zwolan, Mary Beth O'Sullivan, Anita Vereb, Caroline Arnedt, Holly F.B. Teagle, Carolyn J. Brown, Craig A. Buchman, Carlton Zdanski, Hannah Eskridge, Emily Tobey, Andrea Warner-Czyz, Deborah Rekart, Carol Cokely, Nicole Weissner, Angela Boyd, Nancy Fink, Nae Yuh Wang, Daniel Habtemariam, Thelma Vilche, Patricia Bayton

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

21 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The aims of this study were to examine the development of visual attention in deaf and hearing infants and toddlers, and assess whether improvements in visual attention were observed in the deaf sample after 12 months of cochlear implantation. A novel puppet task, based on a measure of attention developed with normally hearing infants, was administered to 88 deaf and 42 normal-hearing children at three time points: baseline, six and 12 months post-implantation for the deaf sample. At baseline, deaf children demonstrated significantly more inattentive looks during the puppet skits than hearing children, and these looks were of longer duration, confirming the results of prior studies which have documented deficits in visual attention in deaf children. Longitudinal analyses showed significant decreases in the frequency of inattentive looks for both groups, with a significant decrease in the duration of inattentive looks only for the cochlear implant group. The largest decrease in duration of off-task looks occurred at six months post-implantation, indicating that improvements occurred rapidly after restoration of auditory input. These results provided support for the 'division of labor' hypothesis which suggests that deaf children with no access or limited access to sound must monitor their environment visually, making it difficult for them to focus and attend to specific tasks. Cochlear implantation appeared to alter the developmental trajectory of visual attention in a positive manner. The clinical implications of visual attention for the development of early language, reading and social skills are discussed.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)242-249
Number of pages8
JournalAudiological Medicine
Volume5
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 15 2007

Fingerprint

Cochlear Implantation
Hearing
Play and Playthings
Language Development
Cochlear Implants
Reading

Keywords

  • 'Division of labor' hypothesis
  • Auditory information
  • Brain plasticity
  • Cochlear implants
  • Visual attention

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Speech and Hearing

Cite this

Quittner, A. L., Barker, D. H., Snell, C., Cruz, I., Mcdonald, L. G., Grimley, M. E., ... Bayton, P. (2007). Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation. Audiological Medicine, 5(4), 242-249. https://doi.org/10.1080/16513860701745401

Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation. / Quittner, Alexandra L.; Barker, David H.; Snell, Carolyn; Cruz, Ivette; Mcdonald, Lynda Grace; Grimley, Mary E.; Botteri, Melissa; Marciel, Kristen; Eisenberg, Laurie; Luxford, William; Johnson, Karen; Martinez, Amy; Des-Jardin, Jean; Visser-Dumont, Leslie; Ambrose, Sophie E; Stika, Carren; Gillinger, Melinda; Niparko, John; Chinnici, Jill; Francis, Howard; Bowditch, Steve; Yeagle, Jennifer; Carver, Courtney; Marlowe, Andrea; Gregg, Andrea; Gross, Jennifer; Ostrander, Rick; Mellon, Nancy; Mertes, Jennifer; O'Leary Kane, Mary; Hodges, Annelle; Balkany, Thomas; Lopez, Alina; Goodwin, Leslie; Zwolan, Teresa; O'Sullivan, Mary Beth; Vereb, Anita; Arnedt, Caroline; Teagle, Holly F.B.; Brown, Carolyn J.; Buchman, Craig A.; Zdanski, Carlton; Eskridge, Hannah; Tobey, Emily; Warner-Czyz, Andrea; Rekart, Deborah; Cokely, Carol; Weissner, Nicole; Boyd, Angela; Fink, Nancy; Wang, Nae Yuh; Habtemariam, Daniel; Vilche, Thelma; Bayton, Patricia.

In: Audiological Medicine, Vol. 5, No. 4, 15.11.2007, p. 242-249.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Quittner, AL, Barker, DH, Snell, C, Cruz, I, Mcdonald, LG, Grimley, ME, Botteri, M, Marciel, K, Eisenberg, L, Luxford, W, Johnson, K, Martinez, A, Des-Jardin, J, Visser-Dumont, L, Ambrose, SE, Stika, C, Gillinger, M, Niparko, J, Chinnici, J, Francis, H, Bowditch, S, Yeagle, J, Carver, C, Marlowe, A, Gregg, A, Gross, J, Ostrander, R, Mellon, N, Mertes, J, O'Leary Kane, M, Hodges, A, Balkany, T, Lopez, A, Goodwin, L, Zwolan, T, O'Sullivan, MB, Vereb, A, Arnedt, C, Teagle, HFB, Brown, CJ, Buchman, CA, Zdanski, C, Eskridge, H, Tobey, E, Warner-Czyz, A, Rekart, D, Cokely, C, Weissner, N, Boyd, A, Fink, N, Wang, NY, Habtemariam, D, Vilche, T & Bayton, P 2007, 'Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation', Audiological Medicine, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 242-249. https://doi.org/10.1080/16513860701745401
Quittner AL, Barker DH, Snell C, Cruz I, Mcdonald LG, Grimley ME et al. Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation. Audiological Medicine. 2007 Nov 15;5(4):242-249. https://doi.org/10.1080/16513860701745401
Quittner, Alexandra L. ; Barker, David H. ; Snell, Carolyn ; Cruz, Ivette ; Mcdonald, Lynda Grace ; Grimley, Mary E. ; Botteri, Melissa ; Marciel, Kristen ; Eisenberg, Laurie ; Luxford, William ; Johnson, Karen ; Martinez, Amy ; Des-Jardin, Jean ; Visser-Dumont, Leslie ; Ambrose, Sophie E ; Stika, Carren ; Gillinger, Melinda ; Niparko, John ; Chinnici, Jill ; Francis, Howard ; Bowditch, Steve ; Yeagle, Jennifer ; Carver, Courtney ; Marlowe, Andrea ; Gregg, Andrea ; Gross, Jennifer ; Ostrander, Rick ; Mellon, Nancy ; Mertes, Jennifer ; O'Leary Kane, Mary ; Hodges, Annelle ; Balkany, Thomas ; Lopez, Alina ; Goodwin, Leslie ; Zwolan, Teresa ; O'Sullivan, Mary Beth ; Vereb, Anita ; Arnedt, Caroline ; Teagle, Holly F.B. ; Brown, Carolyn J. ; Buchman, Craig A. ; Zdanski, Carlton ; Eskridge, Hannah ; Tobey, Emily ; Warner-Czyz, Andrea ; Rekart, Deborah ; Cokely, Carol ; Weissner, Nicole ; Boyd, Angela ; Fink, Nancy ; Wang, Nae Yuh ; Habtemariam, Daniel ; Vilche, Thelma ; Bayton, Patricia. / Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation. In: Audiological Medicine. 2007 ; Vol. 5, No. 4. pp. 242-249.
@article{7336eaadd6e34f41a80adea530ed5f02,
title = "Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation",
abstract = "The aims of this study were to examine the development of visual attention in deaf and hearing infants and toddlers, and assess whether improvements in visual attention were observed in the deaf sample after 12 months of cochlear implantation. A novel puppet task, based on a measure of attention developed with normally hearing infants, was administered to 88 deaf and 42 normal-hearing children at three time points: baseline, six and 12 months post-implantation for the deaf sample. At baseline, deaf children demonstrated significantly more inattentive looks during the puppet skits than hearing children, and these looks were of longer duration, confirming the results of prior studies which have documented deficits in visual attention in deaf children. Longitudinal analyses showed significant decreases in the frequency of inattentive looks for both groups, with a significant decrease in the duration of inattentive looks only for the cochlear implant group. The largest decrease in duration of off-task looks occurred at six months post-implantation, indicating that improvements occurred rapidly after restoration of auditory input. These results provided support for the 'division of labor' hypothesis which suggests that deaf children with no access or limited access to sound must monitor their environment visually, making it difficult for them to focus and attend to specific tasks. Cochlear implantation appeared to alter the developmental trajectory of visual attention in a positive manner. The clinical implications of visual attention for the development of early language, reading and social skills are discussed.",
keywords = "'Division of labor' hypothesis, Auditory information, Brain plasticity, Cochlear implants, Visual attention",
author = "Quittner, {Alexandra L.} and Barker, {David H.} and Carolyn Snell and Ivette Cruz and Mcdonald, {Lynda Grace} and Grimley, {Mary E.} and Melissa Botteri and Kristen Marciel and Laurie Eisenberg and William Luxford and Karen Johnson and Amy Martinez and Jean Des-Jardin and Leslie Visser-Dumont and Ambrose, {Sophie E} and Carren Stika and Melinda Gillinger and John Niparko and Jill Chinnici and Howard Francis and Steve Bowditch and Jennifer Yeagle and Courtney Carver and Andrea Marlowe and Andrea Gregg and Jennifer Gross and Rick Ostrander and Nancy Mellon and Jennifer Mertes and {O'Leary Kane}, Mary and Annelle Hodges and Thomas Balkany and Alina Lopez and Leslie Goodwin and Teresa Zwolan and O'Sullivan, {Mary Beth} and Anita Vereb and Caroline Arnedt and Teagle, {Holly F.B.} and Brown, {Carolyn J.} and Buchman, {Craig A.} and Carlton Zdanski and Hannah Eskridge and Emily Tobey and Andrea Warner-Czyz and Deborah Rekart and Carol Cokely and Nicole Weissner and Angela Boyd and Nancy Fink and Wang, {Nae Yuh} and Daniel Habtemariam and Thelma Vilche and Patricia Bayton",
year = "2007",
month = "11",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1080/16513860701745401",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "5",
pages = "242--249",
journal = "Audiological Medicine",
issn = "1651-386X",
publisher = "Informa Healthcare",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Improvements in visual attention in deaf infants and toddlers after cochlear implantation

AU - Quittner, Alexandra L.

AU - Barker, David H.

AU - Snell, Carolyn

AU - Cruz, Ivette

AU - Mcdonald, Lynda Grace

AU - Grimley, Mary E.

AU - Botteri, Melissa

AU - Marciel, Kristen

AU - Eisenberg, Laurie

AU - Luxford, William

AU - Johnson, Karen

AU - Martinez, Amy

AU - Des-Jardin, Jean

AU - Visser-Dumont, Leslie

AU - Ambrose, Sophie E

AU - Stika, Carren

AU - Gillinger, Melinda

AU - Niparko, John

AU - Chinnici, Jill

AU - Francis, Howard

AU - Bowditch, Steve

AU - Yeagle, Jennifer

AU - Carver, Courtney

AU - Marlowe, Andrea

AU - Gregg, Andrea

AU - Gross, Jennifer

AU - Ostrander, Rick

AU - Mellon, Nancy

AU - Mertes, Jennifer

AU - O'Leary Kane, Mary

AU - Hodges, Annelle

AU - Balkany, Thomas

AU - Lopez, Alina

AU - Goodwin, Leslie

AU - Zwolan, Teresa

AU - O'Sullivan, Mary Beth

AU - Vereb, Anita

AU - Arnedt, Caroline

AU - Teagle, Holly F.B.

AU - Brown, Carolyn J.

AU - Buchman, Craig A.

AU - Zdanski, Carlton

AU - Eskridge, Hannah

AU - Tobey, Emily

AU - Warner-Czyz, Andrea

AU - Rekart, Deborah

AU - Cokely, Carol

AU - Weissner, Nicole

AU - Boyd, Angela

AU - Fink, Nancy

AU - Wang, Nae Yuh

AU - Habtemariam, Daniel

AU - Vilche, Thelma

AU - Bayton, Patricia

PY - 2007/11/15

Y1 - 2007/11/15

N2 - The aims of this study were to examine the development of visual attention in deaf and hearing infants and toddlers, and assess whether improvements in visual attention were observed in the deaf sample after 12 months of cochlear implantation. A novel puppet task, based on a measure of attention developed with normally hearing infants, was administered to 88 deaf and 42 normal-hearing children at three time points: baseline, six and 12 months post-implantation for the deaf sample. At baseline, deaf children demonstrated significantly more inattentive looks during the puppet skits than hearing children, and these looks were of longer duration, confirming the results of prior studies which have documented deficits in visual attention in deaf children. Longitudinal analyses showed significant decreases in the frequency of inattentive looks for both groups, with a significant decrease in the duration of inattentive looks only for the cochlear implant group. The largest decrease in duration of off-task looks occurred at six months post-implantation, indicating that improvements occurred rapidly after restoration of auditory input. These results provided support for the 'division of labor' hypothesis which suggests that deaf children with no access or limited access to sound must monitor their environment visually, making it difficult for them to focus and attend to specific tasks. Cochlear implantation appeared to alter the developmental trajectory of visual attention in a positive manner. The clinical implications of visual attention for the development of early language, reading and social skills are discussed.

AB - The aims of this study were to examine the development of visual attention in deaf and hearing infants and toddlers, and assess whether improvements in visual attention were observed in the deaf sample after 12 months of cochlear implantation. A novel puppet task, based on a measure of attention developed with normally hearing infants, was administered to 88 deaf and 42 normal-hearing children at three time points: baseline, six and 12 months post-implantation for the deaf sample. At baseline, deaf children demonstrated significantly more inattentive looks during the puppet skits than hearing children, and these looks were of longer duration, confirming the results of prior studies which have documented deficits in visual attention in deaf children. Longitudinal analyses showed significant decreases in the frequency of inattentive looks for both groups, with a significant decrease in the duration of inattentive looks only for the cochlear implant group. The largest decrease in duration of off-task looks occurred at six months post-implantation, indicating that improvements occurred rapidly after restoration of auditory input. These results provided support for the 'division of labor' hypothesis which suggests that deaf children with no access or limited access to sound must monitor their environment visually, making it difficult for them to focus and attend to specific tasks. Cochlear implantation appeared to alter the developmental trajectory of visual attention in a positive manner. The clinical implications of visual attention for the development of early language, reading and social skills are discussed.

KW - 'Division of labor' hypothesis

KW - Auditory information

KW - Brain plasticity

KW - Cochlear implants

KW - Visual attention

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=35948985892&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=35948985892&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/16513860701745401

DO - 10.1080/16513860701745401

M3 - Article

VL - 5

SP - 242

EP - 249

JO - Audiological Medicine

JF - Audiological Medicine

SN - 1651-386X

IS - 4

ER -