Human fecal and pathogen exposure pathways in rural Indian villages and the effect of increased latrine coverage

Mitsunori Odagiri, Alexander Schriewer, Miles E. Daniels, Stefan Wuertz, Woutrina A. Smith, Thomas Clasen, Wolf Peter Schmidt, Yujie Jin, Belen Torondel, Pravas R. Misra, Pinaki Panigrahi, Marion W. Jenkins

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

30 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Efforts to eradicate open defecation and improve sanitation access are unlikely to achieve health benefits unless interventions reduce microbial exposures. This study assessed human fecal contamination and pathogen exposures in rural India, and the effect of increased sanitation coverage on contamination and exposure rates. In a cross-sectional study of 60 villages of a cluster-randomized controlled sanitation trial in Odisha, India, human and domestic animal fecal contamination was measured in community tubewells and ponds (n = 301) and via exposure pathways in homes (n = 354), using Bacteroidales microbial source tracking fecal markers validated in India. Community water sources were further tested for diarrheal pathogens (rotavirus, adenovirus and Vibrio cholerae by quantitative PCR; pathogenic Escherichia coli by multiplex PCR; Cryptosporidium and Giardia by immunomagnetic separation and direct fluorescent antibody microscopy). Exposure pathways in intervention and control villages were compared and relationships with child diarrhea examined. Human fecal markers were rarely detected in tubewells (2.4%, 95%CI: 0.3-4.5%) and ponds (5.6%, 95%CI: 0.8-10.3%), compared to homes (35.4%, 95%CI: 30.4-40.4%). In tubewells, V. cholerae was the most frequently detected pathogen (19.8%, 95%CI: 14.4-25.2%), followed by Giardia (14.8%, 95%CI: 10.0-19.7%). In ponds, Giardia was most often detected (74.5%, 95%CI: 65.7-83.3%), followed by pathogenic E. coli (48.1%, 95%CI: 34.8-61.5%) and rotavirus (44.4%, 95%CI: 34.2-54.7%). At village-level, prevalence of fecal pathogen detection in community drinking water sources was associated with elevated prevalence of child diarrhea within 6 weeks of testing (RR 2.13, 95%CI: 1.25-3.63) while within homes, higher levels of human and animal fecal marker detection were associated with increased risks of subsequent child diarrhea (P = 0.044 and 0.013, respectively). There was no evidence that the intervention, which increased functional latrine coverage and use by 27 percentage points, reduced human fecal contamination in any tested pathway, nor the prevalence of pathogens in water sources. In conclusion, the study demonstrates that (1) improved sanitation alone may be insufficient and further interventions needed in the domestic domain to reduce widespread human and animal fecal contamination observed in homes, (2) pathogens detected in tubewells indicate these sources are microbiologically unsafe for drinking and were associated with child diarrhea, (3) domestic use of ponds heavily contaminated with multiple pathogens presents an under-recognized health risk, and (4) a 27 percentage point increase in improved sanitation access at village-level did not reduce detectable human fecal and pathogen contamination in this setting.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)232-244
Number of pages13
JournalWater Research
Volume100
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2016

Fingerprint

Pathogens
Sanitation
village
pathogen
sanitation
Contamination
Ponds
pond
Animals
cholera
Escherichia coli
animal
defecation
exposure
effect
Health risks
drinking
Antibodies
Potable water
health risk

Keywords

  • Bacteroidales
  • Child diarrhea prevalence
  • Drinking water contamination
  • Hand contamination
  • Improved sanitation
  • Microbial source tracking

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecological Modeling
  • Water Science and Technology
  • Waste Management and Disposal
  • Pollution

Cite this

Odagiri, M., Schriewer, A., Daniels, M. E., Wuertz, S., Smith, W. A., Clasen, T., ... Jenkins, M. W. (2016). Human fecal and pathogen exposure pathways in rural Indian villages and the effect of increased latrine coverage. Water Research, 100, 232-244. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2016.05.015

Human fecal and pathogen exposure pathways in rural Indian villages and the effect of increased latrine coverage. / Odagiri, Mitsunori; Schriewer, Alexander; Daniels, Miles E.; Wuertz, Stefan; Smith, Woutrina A.; Clasen, Thomas; Schmidt, Wolf Peter; Jin, Yujie; Torondel, Belen; Misra, Pravas R.; Panigrahi, Pinaki; Jenkins, Marion W.

In: Water Research, Vol. 100, 01.09.2016, p. 232-244.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Odagiri, M, Schriewer, A, Daniels, ME, Wuertz, S, Smith, WA, Clasen, T, Schmidt, WP, Jin, Y, Torondel, B, Misra, PR, Panigrahi, P & Jenkins, MW 2016, 'Human fecal and pathogen exposure pathways in rural Indian villages and the effect of increased latrine coverage', Water Research, vol. 100, pp. 232-244. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2016.05.015
Odagiri, Mitsunori ; Schriewer, Alexander ; Daniels, Miles E. ; Wuertz, Stefan ; Smith, Woutrina A. ; Clasen, Thomas ; Schmidt, Wolf Peter ; Jin, Yujie ; Torondel, Belen ; Misra, Pravas R. ; Panigrahi, Pinaki ; Jenkins, Marion W. / Human fecal and pathogen exposure pathways in rural Indian villages and the effect of increased latrine coverage. In: Water Research. 2016 ; Vol. 100. pp. 232-244.
@article{6f136a96e8804068937f6386c42dee0b,
title = "Human fecal and pathogen exposure pathways in rural Indian villages and the effect of increased latrine coverage",
abstract = "Efforts to eradicate open defecation and improve sanitation access are unlikely to achieve health benefits unless interventions reduce microbial exposures. This study assessed human fecal contamination and pathogen exposures in rural India, and the effect of increased sanitation coverage on contamination and exposure rates. In a cross-sectional study of 60 villages of a cluster-randomized controlled sanitation trial in Odisha, India, human and domestic animal fecal contamination was measured in community tubewells and ponds (n = 301) and via exposure pathways in homes (n = 354), using Bacteroidales microbial source tracking fecal markers validated in India. Community water sources were further tested for diarrheal pathogens (rotavirus, adenovirus and Vibrio cholerae by quantitative PCR; pathogenic Escherichia coli by multiplex PCR; Cryptosporidium and Giardia by immunomagnetic separation and direct fluorescent antibody microscopy). Exposure pathways in intervention and control villages were compared and relationships with child diarrhea examined. Human fecal markers were rarely detected in tubewells (2.4{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 0.3-4.5{\%}) and ponds (5.6{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 0.8-10.3{\%}), compared to homes (35.4{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 30.4-40.4{\%}). In tubewells, V. cholerae was the most frequently detected pathogen (19.8{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 14.4-25.2{\%}), followed by Giardia (14.8{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 10.0-19.7{\%}). In ponds, Giardia was most often detected (74.5{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 65.7-83.3{\%}), followed by pathogenic E. coli (48.1{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 34.8-61.5{\%}) and rotavirus (44.4{\%}, 95{\%}CI: 34.2-54.7{\%}). At village-level, prevalence of fecal pathogen detection in community drinking water sources was associated with elevated prevalence of child diarrhea within 6 weeks of testing (RR 2.13, 95{\%}CI: 1.25-3.63) while within homes, higher levels of human and animal fecal marker detection were associated with increased risks of subsequent child diarrhea (P = 0.044 and 0.013, respectively). There was no evidence that the intervention, which increased functional latrine coverage and use by 27 percentage points, reduced human fecal contamination in any tested pathway, nor the prevalence of pathogens in water sources. In conclusion, the study demonstrates that (1) improved sanitation alone may be insufficient and further interventions needed in the domestic domain to reduce widespread human and animal fecal contamination observed in homes, (2) pathogens detected in tubewells indicate these sources are microbiologically unsafe for drinking and were associated with child diarrhea, (3) domestic use of ponds heavily contaminated with multiple pathogens presents an under-recognized health risk, and (4) a 27 percentage point increase in improved sanitation access at village-level did not reduce detectable human fecal and pathogen contamination in this setting.",
keywords = "Bacteroidales, Child diarrhea prevalence, Drinking water contamination, Hand contamination, Improved sanitation, Microbial source tracking",
author = "Mitsunori Odagiri and Alexander Schriewer and Daniels, {Miles E.} and Stefan Wuertz and Smith, {Woutrina A.} and Thomas Clasen and Schmidt, {Wolf Peter} and Yujie Jin and Belen Torondel and Misra, {Pravas R.} and Pinaki Panigrahi and Jenkins, {Marion W.}",
year = "2016",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.watres.2016.05.015",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "100",
pages = "232--244",
journal = "Water Research",
issn = "0043-1354",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Human fecal and pathogen exposure pathways in rural Indian villages and the effect of increased latrine coverage

AU - Odagiri, Mitsunori

AU - Schriewer, Alexander

AU - Daniels, Miles E.

AU - Wuertz, Stefan

AU - Smith, Woutrina A.

AU - Clasen, Thomas

AU - Schmidt, Wolf Peter

AU - Jin, Yujie

AU - Torondel, Belen

AU - Misra, Pravas R.

AU - Panigrahi, Pinaki

AU - Jenkins, Marion W.

PY - 2016/9/1

Y1 - 2016/9/1

N2 - Efforts to eradicate open defecation and improve sanitation access are unlikely to achieve health benefits unless interventions reduce microbial exposures. This study assessed human fecal contamination and pathogen exposures in rural India, and the effect of increased sanitation coverage on contamination and exposure rates. In a cross-sectional study of 60 villages of a cluster-randomized controlled sanitation trial in Odisha, India, human and domestic animal fecal contamination was measured in community tubewells and ponds (n = 301) and via exposure pathways in homes (n = 354), using Bacteroidales microbial source tracking fecal markers validated in India. Community water sources were further tested for diarrheal pathogens (rotavirus, adenovirus and Vibrio cholerae by quantitative PCR; pathogenic Escherichia coli by multiplex PCR; Cryptosporidium and Giardia by immunomagnetic separation and direct fluorescent antibody microscopy). Exposure pathways in intervention and control villages were compared and relationships with child diarrhea examined. Human fecal markers were rarely detected in tubewells (2.4%, 95%CI: 0.3-4.5%) and ponds (5.6%, 95%CI: 0.8-10.3%), compared to homes (35.4%, 95%CI: 30.4-40.4%). In tubewells, V. cholerae was the most frequently detected pathogen (19.8%, 95%CI: 14.4-25.2%), followed by Giardia (14.8%, 95%CI: 10.0-19.7%). In ponds, Giardia was most often detected (74.5%, 95%CI: 65.7-83.3%), followed by pathogenic E. coli (48.1%, 95%CI: 34.8-61.5%) and rotavirus (44.4%, 95%CI: 34.2-54.7%). At village-level, prevalence of fecal pathogen detection in community drinking water sources was associated with elevated prevalence of child diarrhea within 6 weeks of testing (RR 2.13, 95%CI: 1.25-3.63) while within homes, higher levels of human and animal fecal marker detection were associated with increased risks of subsequent child diarrhea (P = 0.044 and 0.013, respectively). There was no evidence that the intervention, which increased functional latrine coverage and use by 27 percentage points, reduced human fecal contamination in any tested pathway, nor the prevalence of pathogens in water sources. In conclusion, the study demonstrates that (1) improved sanitation alone may be insufficient and further interventions needed in the domestic domain to reduce widespread human and animal fecal contamination observed in homes, (2) pathogens detected in tubewells indicate these sources are microbiologically unsafe for drinking and were associated with child diarrhea, (3) domestic use of ponds heavily contaminated with multiple pathogens presents an under-recognized health risk, and (4) a 27 percentage point increase in improved sanitation access at village-level did not reduce detectable human fecal and pathogen contamination in this setting.

AB - Efforts to eradicate open defecation and improve sanitation access are unlikely to achieve health benefits unless interventions reduce microbial exposures. This study assessed human fecal contamination and pathogen exposures in rural India, and the effect of increased sanitation coverage on contamination and exposure rates. In a cross-sectional study of 60 villages of a cluster-randomized controlled sanitation trial in Odisha, India, human and domestic animal fecal contamination was measured in community tubewells and ponds (n = 301) and via exposure pathways in homes (n = 354), using Bacteroidales microbial source tracking fecal markers validated in India. Community water sources were further tested for diarrheal pathogens (rotavirus, adenovirus and Vibrio cholerae by quantitative PCR; pathogenic Escherichia coli by multiplex PCR; Cryptosporidium and Giardia by immunomagnetic separation and direct fluorescent antibody microscopy). Exposure pathways in intervention and control villages were compared and relationships with child diarrhea examined. Human fecal markers were rarely detected in tubewells (2.4%, 95%CI: 0.3-4.5%) and ponds (5.6%, 95%CI: 0.8-10.3%), compared to homes (35.4%, 95%CI: 30.4-40.4%). In tubewells, V. cholerae was the most frequently detected pathogen (19.8%, 95%CI: 14.4-25.2%), followed by Giardia (14.8%, 95%CI: 10.0-19.7%). In ponds, Giardia was most often detected (74.5%, 95%CI: 65.7-83.3%), followed by pathogenic E. coli (48.1%, 95%CI: 34.8-61.5%) and rotavirus (44.4%, 95%CI: 34.2-54.7%). At village-level, prevalence of fecal pathogen detection in community drinking water sources was associated with elevated prevalence of child diarrhea within 6 weeks of testing (RR 2.13, 95%CI: 1.25-3.63) while within homes, higher levels of human and animal fecal marker detection were associated with increased risks of subsequent child diarrhea (P = 0.044 and 0.013, respectively). There was no evidence that the intervention, which increased functional latrine coverage and use by 27 percentage points, reduced human fecal contamination in any tested pathway, nor the prevalence of pathogens in water sources. In conclusion, the study demonstrates that (1) improved sanitation alone may be insufficient and further interventions needed in the domestic domain to reduce widespread human and animal fecal contamination observed in homes, (2) pathogens detected in tubewells indicate these sources are microbiologically unsafe for drinking and were associated with child diarrhea, (3) domestic use of ponds heavily contaminated with multiple pathogens presents an under-recognized health risk, and (4) a 27 percentage point increase in improved sanitation access at village-level did not reduce detectable human fecal and pathogen contamination in this setting.

KW - Bacteroidales

KW - Child diarrhea prevalence

KW - Drinking water contamination

KW - Hand contamination

KW - Improved sanitation

KW - Microbial source tracking

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84966714178&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84966714178&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.watres.2016.05.015

DO - 10.1016/j.watres.2016.05.015

M3 - Article

C2 - 27192358

AN - SCOPUS:84966714178

VL - 100

SP - 232

EP - 244

JO - Water Research

JF - Water Research

SN - 0043-1354

ER -