How Do Teachers Use Comics to Promote Engagement, Equity, and Diversity in Science Classrooms?

Camillia Matuk, Talia Hurwich, Amy N Spiegel, Judy Diamond

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Equitable learning opportunities are critical to the goals of science education. However, major curriculum standards are vague on how to achieve equity goals, and educators must often develop their own resources and strategies to achieve equity goals. This study examines how educators used a comic book series designed to interest youth in virology as a way to make science more broadly appealing to their diverse students. We begin with the notion of Pedagogical Design Capacity, which describes a dynamic relationship between teachers and their tools and the ability for teachers to perceive and leverage affordances of artifacts as tools in their curriculum design. In a qualitative analysis of 18 interviews with educators, survey responses, instructional artifacts, and classroom observations, we describe the potential that educators saw in the comics and the strategies they used to take advantage of that potential to promote equitable science teaching. Notably, we observed how the comics enabled educators to incorporate multiple literacies and disciplinary lenses into their lessons, thereby expanding traditional views of science literacy. We documented the range of techniques by which they used comics and fictional narratives to support specific scientific practices, such as modeling. We also observed challenges that participants encountered in using comics, which included overcoming their own and their students’ attitudes and beliefs regarding the role of informal reading materials in science education. By investigating how resourceful science educators use comic books, this study informs both researchers and educators on how innovative curriculum materials can broaden and diversify participation in science. Findings have implications for the design of similar curriculum materials and instructional approaches, as well as professional development to support equitable science teaching.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalResearch in Science Education
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

equity
classroom
educator
teacher
science
curriculum
artifact
Teaching
education
student
literacy
narrative
participation
ability
interview
resources
learning

Keywords

  • Classrooms
  • Comic books
  • Equity
  • Instructional strategies
  • Science education
  • Teachers

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

How Do Teachers Use Comics to Promote Engagement, Equity, and Diversity in Science Classrooms? / Matuk, Camillia; Hurwich, Talia; Spiegel, Amy N; Diamond, Judy.

In: Research in Science Education, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9de39a3335634ba196ec1d6e73086a2b,
title = "How Do Teachers Use Comics to Promote Engagement, Equity, and Diversity in Science Classrooms?",
abstract = "Equitable learning opportunities are critical to the goals of science education. However, major curriculum standards are vague on how to achieve equity goals, and educators must often develop their own resources and strategies to achieve equity goals. This study examines how educators used a comic book series designed to interest youth in virology as a way to make science more broadly appealing to their diverse students. We begin with the notion of Pedagogical Design Capacity, which describes a dynamic relationship between teachers and their tools and the ability for teachers to perceive and leverage affordances of artifacts as tools in their curriculum design. In a qualitative analysis of 18 interviews with educators, survey responses, instructional artifacts, and classroom observations, we describe the potential that educators saw in the comics and the strategies they used to take advantage of that potential to promote equitable science teaching. Notably, we observed how the comics enabled educators to incorporate multiple literacies and disciplinary lenses into their lessons, thereby expanding traditional views of science literacy. We documented the range of techniques by which they used comics and fictional narratives to support specific scientific practices, such as modeling. We also observed challenges that participants encountered in using comics, which included overcoming their own and their students’ attitudes and beliefs regarding the role of informal reading materials in science education. By investigating how resourceful science educators use comic books, this study informs both researchers and educators on how innovative curriculum materials can broaden and diversify participation in science. Findings have implications for the design of similar curriculum materials and instructional approaches, as well as professional development to support equitable science teaching.",
keywords = "Classrooms, Comic books, Equity, Instructional strategies, Science education, Teachers",
author = "Camillia Matuk and Talia Hurwich and Spiegel, {Amy N} and Judy Diamond",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s11165-018-9814-8",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Research in Science Education",
issn = "0157-244X",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - How Do Teachers Use Comics to Promote Engagement, Equity, and Diversity in Science Classrooms?

AU - Matuk, Camillia

AU - Hurwich, Talia

AU - Spiegel, Amy N

AU - Diamond, Judy

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Equitable learning opportunities are critical to the goals of science education. However, major curriculum standards are vague on how to achieve equity goals, and educators must often develop their own resources and strategies to achieve equity goals. This study examines how educators used a comic book series designed to interest youth in virology as a way to make science more broadly appealing to their diverse students. We begin with the notion of Pedagogical Design Capacity, which describes a dynamic relationship between teachers and their tools and the ability for teachers to perceive and leverage affordances of artifacts as tools in their curriculum design. In a qualitative analysis of 18 interviews with educators, survey responses, instructional artifacts, and classroom observations, we describe the potential that educators saw in the comics and the strategies they used to take advantage of that potential to promote equitable science teaching. Notably, we observed how the comics enabled educators to incorporate multiple literacies and disciplinary lenses into their lessons, thereby expanding traditional views of science literacy. We documented the range of techniques by which they used comics and fictional narratives to support specific scientific practices, such as modeling. We also observed challenges that participants encountered in using comics, which included overcoming their own and their students’ attitudes and beliefs regarding the role of informal reading materials in science education. By investigating how resourceful science educators use comic books, this study informs both researchers and educators on how innovative curriculum materials can broaden and diversify participation in science. Findings have implications for the design of similar curriculum materials and instructional approaches, as well as professional development to support equitable science teaching.

AB - Equitable learning opportunities are critical to the goals of science education. However, major curriculum standards are vague on how to achieve equity goals, and educators must often develop their own resources and strategies to achieve equity goals. This study examines how educators used a comic book series designed to interest youth in virology as a way to make science more broadly appealing to their diverse students. We begin with the notion of Pedagogical Design Capacity, which describes a dynamic relationship between teachers and their tools and the ability for teachers to perceive and leverage affordances of artifacts as tools in their curriculum design. In a qualitative analysis of 18 interviews with educators, survey responses, instructional artifacts, and classroom observations, we describe the potential that educators saw in the comics and the strategies they used to take advantage of that potential to promote equitable science teaching. Notably, we observed how the comics enabled educators to incorporate multiple literacies and disciplinary lenses into their lessons, thereby expanding traditional views of science literacy. We documented the range of techniques by which they used comics and fictional narratives to support specific scientific practices, such as modeling. We also observed challenges that participants encountered in using comics, which included overcoming their own and their students’ attitudes and beliefs regarding the role of informal reading materials in science education. By investigating how resourceful science educators use comic books, this study informs both researchers and educators on how innovative curriculum materials can broaden and diversify participation in science. Findings have implications for the design of similar curriculum materials and instructional approaches, as well as professional development to support equitable science teaching.

KW - Classrooms

KW - Comic books

KW - Equity

KW - Instructional strategies

KW - Science education

KW - Teachers

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85059872429&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85059872429&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11165-018-9814-8

DO - 10.1007/s11165-018-9814-8

M3 - Article

JO - Research in Science Education

JF - Research in Science Education

SN - 0157-244X

ER -