Famous face identification in temporal lobe epilepsy

Support for a multimodal integration model of semantic memory

Daniel L. Drane, Jeffrey G. Ojemann, Vaishali S Phatak, David W. Loring, Robert E. Gross, Adam O. Hebb, Daniel L. Silbergeld, John W. Miller, Natalie L. Voets, Amit M. Saindane, Lawrence Barsalou, Kimford J. Meador, George A. Ojemann, Daniel Tranel

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

46 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This study aims to demonstrate that the left and right anterior temporal lobes (ATLs) perform critical but unique roles in famous face identification, with damage to either leading to differing deficit patterns reflecting decreased access to lexical or semantic concepts but not their degradation. Famous face identification was studied in 22 presurgical and 14 postsurgical temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) patients and 20 healthy comparison subjects using free recall and multiple choice (MC) paradigms. Right TLE patients exhibited presurgical deficits in famous face recognition, and postsurgical deficits in both famous face recognition and familiarity judgments. However, they did not exhibit any problems with naming before or after surgery. In contrast, left TLE patients demonstrated both pre- and postsurgical deficits in famous face naming but no significant deficits in recognition or familiarity. Double dissociations in performance between groups were alleviated by altering task demands. Postsurgical right TLE patients provided with MC options correctly identified greater than 70% of famous faces they initially rated as unfamiliar. Left TLE patients accurately chose the name for nearly all famous faces they recognized (based on their verbal description) but initially failed to name, although they tended to rapidly lose access to this name. We believe alterations in task demands activate alternative routes to semantic and lexical networks, demonstrating that unique pathways to such stored information exist, and suggesting a different role for each ATL in identifying visually presented famous faces. The right ATL appears to play a fundamental role in accessing semantic information from a visual route, with the left ATL serving to link semantic information to the language system to produce a specific name. These findings challenge several assumptions underlying amodal models of semantic memory, and provide support for the integrated multimodal theories of semantic memory and a distributed representation of concepts.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1648-1667
Number of pages20
JournalCortex
Volume49
Issue number6
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 1 2013

Fingerprint

Temporal Lobe Epilepsy
Semantics
Temporal Lobe
Names
Healthy Volunteers
Language
Recognition (Psychology)

Keywords

  • Epilepsy surgery
  • Famous face naming and recognition
  • Models of semantic memory

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neuropsychology and Physiological Psychology
  • Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
  • Cognitive Neuroscience

Cite this

Famous face identification in temporal lobe epilepsy : Support for a multimodal integration model of semantic memory. / Drane, Daniel L.; Ojemann, Jeffrey G.; Phatak, Vaishali S; Loring, David W.; Gross, Robert E.; Hebb, Adam O.; Silbergeld, Daniel L.; Miller, John W.; Voets, Natalie L.; Saindane, Amit M.; Barsalou, Lawrence; Meador, Kimford J.; Ojemann, George A.; Tranel, Daniel.

In: Cortex, Vol. 49, No. 6, 01.06.2013, p. 1648-1667.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Drane, DL, Ojemann, JG, Phatak, VS, Loring, DW, Gross, RE, Hebb, AO, Silbergeld, DL, Miller, JW, Voets, NL, Saindane, AM, Barsalou, L, Meador, KJ, Ojemann, GA & Tranel, D 2013, 'Famous face identification in temporal lobe epilepsy: Support for a multimodal integration model of semantic memory', Cortex, vol. 49, no. 6, pp. 1648-1667. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cortex.2012.08.009
Drane, Daniel L. ; Ojemann, Jeffrey G. ; Phatak, Vaishali S ; Loring, David W. ; Gross, Robert E. ; Hebb, Adam O. ; Silbergeld, Daniel L. ; Miller, John W. ; Voets, Natalie L. ; Saindane, Amit M. ; Barsalou, Lawrence ; Meador, Kimford J. ; Ojemann, George A. ; Tranel, Daniel. / Famous face identification in temporal lobe epilepsy : Support for a multimodal integration model of semantic memory. In: Cortex. 2013 ; Vol. 49, No. 6. pp. 1648-1667.
@article{7c143ad1585349caae61de871e50cb9c,
title = "Famous face identification in temporal lobe epilepsy: Support for a multimodal integration model of semantic memory",
abstract = "This study aims to demonstrate that the left and right anterior temporal lobes (ATLs) perform critical but unique roles in famous face identification, with damage to either leading to differing deficit patterns reflecting decreased access to lexical or semantic concepts but not their degradation. Famous face identification was studied in 22 presurgical and 14 postsurgical temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) patients and 20 healthy comparison subjects using free recall and multiple choice (MC) paradigms. Right TLE patients exhibited presurgical deficits in famous face recognition, and postsurgical deficits in both famous face recognition and familiarity judgments. However, they did not exhibit any problems with naming before or after surgery. In contrast, left TLE patients demonstrated both pre- and postsurgical deficits in famous face naming but no significant deficits in recognition or familiarity. Double dissociations in performance between groups were alleviated by altering task demands. Postsurgical right TLE patients provided with MC options correctly identified greater than 70{\%} of famous faces they initially rated as unfamiliar. Left TLE patients accurately chose the name for nearly all famous faces they recognized (based on their verbal description) but initially failed to name, although they tended to rapidly lose access to this name. We believe alterations in task demands activate alternative routes to semantic and lexical networks, demonstrating that unique pathways to such stored information exist, and suggesting a different role for each ATL in identifying visually presented famous faces. The right ATL appears to play a fundamental role in accessing semantic information from a visual route, with the left ATL serving to link semantic information to the language system to produce a specific name. These findings challenge several assumptions underlying amodal models of semantic memory, and provide support for the integrated multimodal theories of semantic memory and a distributed representation of concepts.",
keywords = "Epilepsy surgery, Famous face naming and recognition, Models of semantic memory",
author = "Drane, {Daniel L.} and Ojemann, {Jeffrey G.} and Phatak, {Vaishali S} and Loring, {David W.} and Gross, {Robert E.} and Hebb, {Adam O.} and Silbergeld, {Daniel L.} and Miller, {John W.} and Voets, {Natalie L.} and Saindane, {Amit M.} and Lawrence Barsalou and Meador, {Kimford J.} and Ojemann, {George A.} and Daniel Tranel",
year = "2013",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.cortex.2012.08.009",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "49",
pages = "1648--1667",
journal = "Cortex",
issn = "0010-9452",
publisher = "Masson SpA",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Famous face identification in temporal lobe epilepsy

T2 - Support for a multimodal integration model of semantic memory

AU - Drane, Daniel L.

AU - Ojemann, Jeffrey G.

AU - Phatak, Vaishali S

AU - Loring, David W.

AU - Gross, Robert E.

AU - Hebb, Adam O.

AU - Silbergeld, Daniel L.

AU - Miller, John W.

AU - Voets, Natalie L.

AU - Saindane, Amit M.

AU - Barsalou, Lawrence

AU - Meador, Kimford J.

AU - Ojemann, George A.

AU - Tranel, Daniel

PY - 2013/6/1

Y1 - 2013/6/1

N2 - This study aims to demonstrate that the left and right anterior temporal lobes (ATLs) perform critical but unique roles in famous face identification, with damage to either leading to differing deficit patterns reflecting decreased access to lexical or semantic concepts but not their degradation. Famous face identification was studied in 22 presurgical and 14 postsurgical temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) patients and 20 healthy comparison subjects using free recall and multiple choice (MC) paradigms. Right TLE patients exhibited presurgical deficits in famous face recognition, and postsurgical deficits in both famous face recognition and familiarity judgments. However, they did not exhibit any problems with naming before or after surgery. In contrast, left TLE patients demonstrated both pre- and postsurgical deficits in famous face naming but no significant deficits in recognition or familiarity. Double dissociations in performance between groups were alleviated by altering task demands. Postsurgical right TLE patients provided with MC options correctly identified greater than 70% of famous faces they initially rated as unfamiliar. Left TLE patients accurately chose the name for nearly all famous faces they recognized (based on their verbal description) but initially failed to name, although they tended to rapidly lose access to this name. We believe alterations in task demands activate alternative routes to semantic and lexical networks, demonstrating that unique pathways to such stored information exist, and suggesting a different role for each ATL in identifying visually presented famous faces. The right ATL appears to play a fundamental role in accessing semantic information from a visual route, with the left ATL serving to link semantic information to the language system to produce a specific name. These findings challenge several assumptions underlying amodal models of semantic memory, and provide support for the integrated multimodal theories of semantic memory and a distributed representation of concepts.

AB - This study aims to demonstrate that the left and right anterior temporal lobes (ATLs) perform critical but unique roles in famous face identification, with damage to either leading to differing deficit patterns reflecting decreased access to lexical or semantic concepts but not their degradation. Famous face identification was studied in 22 presurgical and 14 postsurgical temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) patients and 20 healthy comparison subjects using free recall and multiple choice (MC) paradigms. Right TLE patients exhibited presurgical deficits in famous face recognition, and postsurgical deficits in both famous face recognition and familiarity judgments. However, they did not exhibit any problems with naming before or after surgery. In contrast, left TLE patients demonstrated both pre- and postsurgical deficits in famous face naming but no significant deficits in recognition or familiarity. Double dissociations in performance between groups were alleviated by altering task demands. Postsurgical right TLE patients provided with MC options correctly identified greater than 70% of famous faces they initially rated as unfamiliar. Left TLE patients accurately chose the name for nearly all famous faces they recognized (based on their verbal description) but initially failed to name, although they tended to rapidly lose access to this name. We believe alterations in task demands activate alternative routes to semantic and lexical networks, demonstrating that unique pathways to such stored information exist, and suggesting a different role for each ATL in identifying visually presented famous faces. The right ATL appears to play a fundamental role in accessing semantic information from a visual route, with the left ATL serving to link semantic information to the language system to produce a specific name. These findings challenge several assumptions underlying amodal models of semantic memory, and provide support for the integrated multimodal theories of semantic memory and a distributed representation of concepts.

KW - Epilepsy surgery

KW - Famous face naming and recognition

KW - Models of semantic memory

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84878911865&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84878911865&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.cortex.2012.08.009

DO - 10.1016/j.cortex.2012.08.009

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 1648

EP - 1667

JO - Cortex

JF - Cortex

SN - 0010-9452

IS - 6

ER -