Coverage error of commercial skin pigments as compared to human facial skin tones

Elizabeth Hungerford, Mark W Beatty, David B. Marx, Bobby Simetich, Alvin G. Wee

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objectives It is unknown if present-day pigments used for intrinsic colouration of maxillofacial prostheses are representative of human facial skin tones. This study's purpose was to measure L*a*b* values of pigmented elastomers coloured by eleven skin tone pigments and determine coverage error (CE) when the pigments were compared to human facial lip and nose colour data. Methods 11 skin tone pigments were combined at 0.1%, 1% and 10% by weight with A-2186 elastomer (n = 3). L*a*b* values were measured with a spectrophotometer and group means were used to calculate ΔE* colour differences with each L*a*b* value obtained for human nose and lip. Pigmented elastomer CEs were calculated for nose and lip. Results were compared to CEs for proposed shade guide colours obtained from clustering analyses of facial skin colours. Results L* values of pigmented elastomers generally were higher than those measured for nose and lip, whereas a* values were lower. CEs for pigmented elastomers were higher than those obtained from the proposed shade guide obtained from clustered skin measurements. Conclusions Overall, the current commercial elastomers appeared to be too white and not red enough to adequately match the skin tones of the subject population. Adjustments must be made to the existing pigmenting system in order to adequately match the skin colours of the study population. Clinical significance The creation of a shade guide and a collection of intrinsic pigments representing the realm of human facial skin colours would greatly decrease the time a patient must sit while the clinician is obtaining an acceptable colour match for the silicone to be used for processing the final prosthesis, thereby increasing both patient satisfaction and clinician productivity.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)986-991
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Dentistry
Volume41
Issue number11
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2013

Fingerprint

Skin Pigmentation
Elastomers
Skin
Lip
Nose
Color
Maxillofacial Prosthesis
Silicones
Patient Satisfaction
Population
Prostheses and Implants
Cluster Analysis
Weights and Measures

Keywords

  • Aesthetics
  • Colour differences
  • Maxillofacial elastomer
  • Prosthesis colouring

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dentistry(all)
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Coverage error of commercial skin pigments as compared to human facial skin tones. / Hungerford, Elizabeth; Beatty, Mark W; Marx, David B.; Simetich, Bobby; Wee, Alvin G.

In: Journal of Dentistry, Vol. 41, No. 11, 01.11.2013, p. 986-991.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hungerford, Elizabeth ; Beatty, Mark W ; Marx, David B. ; Simetich, Bobby ; Wee, Alvin G. / Coverage error of commercial skin pigments as compared to human facial skin tones. In: Journal of Dentistry. 2013 ; Vol. 41, No. 11. pp. 986-991.
@article{6027c328bb574405a137087c43551578,
title = "Coverage error of commercial skin pigments as compared to human facial skin tones",
abstract = "Objectives It is unknown if present-day pigments used for intrinsic colouration of maxillofacial prostheses are representative of human facial skin tones. This study's purpose was to measure L*a*b* values of pigmented elastomers coloured by eleven skin tone pigments and determine coverage error (CE) when the pigments were compared to human facial lip and nose colour data. Methods 11 skin tone pigments were combined at 0.1{\%}, 1{\%} and 10{\%} by weight with A-2186 elastomer (n = 3). L*a*b* values were measured with a spectrophotometer and group means were used to calculate ΔE* colour differences with each L*a*b* value obtained for human nose and lip. Pigmented elastomer CEs were calculated for nose and lip. Results were compared to CEs for proposed shade guide colours obtained from clustering analyses of facial skin colours. Results L* values of pigmented elastomers generally were higher than those measured for nose and lip, whereas a* values were lower. CEs for pigmented elastomers were higher than those obtained from the proposed shade guide obtained from clustered skin measurements. Conclusions Overall, the current commercial elastomers appeared to be too white and not red enough to adequately match the skin tones of the subject population. Adjustments must be made to the existing pigmenting system in order to adequately match the skin colours of the study population. Clinical significance The creation of a shade guide and a collection of intrinsic pigments representing the realm of human facial skin colours would greatly decrease the time a patient must sit while the clinician is obtaining an acceptable colour match for the silicone to be used for processing the final prosthesis, thereby increasing both patient satisfaction and clinician productivity.",
keywords = "Aesthetics, Colour differences, Maxillofacial elastomer, Prosthesis colouring",
author = "Elizabeth Hungerford and Beatty, {Mark W} and Marx, {David B.} and Bobby Simetich and Wee, {Alvin G.}",
year = "2013",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jdent.2013.07.010",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "41",
pages = "986--991",
journal = "Journal of Dentistry",
issn = "0300-5712",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Coverage error of commercial skin pigments as compared to human facial skin tones

AU - Hungerford, Elizabeth

AU - Beatty, Mark W

AU - Marx, David B.

AU - Simetich, Bobby

AU - Wee, Alvin G.

PY - 2013/11/1

Y1 - 2013/11/1

N2 - Objectives It is unknown if present-day pigments used for intrinsic colouration of maxillofacial prostheses are representative of human facial skin tones. This study's purpose was to measure L*a*b* values of pigmented elastomers coloured by eleven skin tone pigments and determine coverage error (CE) when the pigments were compared to human facial lip and nose colour data. Methods 11 skin tone pigments were combined at 0.1%, 1% and 10% by weight with A-2186 elastomer (n = 3). L*a*b* values were measured with a spectrophotometer and group means were used to calculate ΔE* colour differences with each L*a*b* value obtained for human nose and lip. Pigmented elastomer CEs were calculated for nose and lip. Results were compared to CEs for proposed shade guide colours obtained from clustering analyses of facial skin colours. Results L* values of pigmented elastomers generally were higher than those measured for nose and lip, whereas a* values were lower. CEs for pigmented elastomers were higher than those obtained from the proposed shade guide obtained from clustered skin measurements. Conclusions Overall, the current commercial elastomers appeared to be too white and not red enough to adequately match the skin tones of the subject population. Adjustments must be made to the existing pigmenting system in order to adequately match the skin colours of the study population. Clinical significance The creation of a shade guide and a collection of intrinsic pigments representing the realm of human facial skin colours would greatly decrease the time a patient must sit while the clinician is obtaining an acceptable colour match for the silicone to be used for processing the final prosthesis, thereby increasing both patient satisfaction and clinician productivity.

AB - Objectives It is unknown if present-day pigments used for intrinsic colouration of maxillofacial prostheses are representative of human facial skin tones. This study's purpose was to measure L*a*b* values of pigmented elastomers coloured by eleven skin tone pigments and determine coverage error (CE) when the pigments were compared to human facial lip and nose colour data. Methods 11 skin tone pigments were combined at 0.1%, 1% and 10% by weight with A-2186 elastomer (n = 3). L*a*b* values were measured with a spectrophotometer and group means were used to calculate ΔE* colour differences with each L*a*b* value obtained for human nose and lip. Pigmented elastomer CEs were calculated for nose and lip. Results were compared to CEs for proposed shade guide colours obtained from clustering analyses of facial skin colours. Results L* values of pigmented elastomers generally were higher than those measured for nose and lip, whereas a* values were lower. CEs for pigmented elastomers were higher than those obtained from the proposed shade guide obtained from clustered skin measurements. Conclusions Overall, the current commercial elastomers appeared to be too white and not red enough to adequately match the skin tones of the subject population. Adjustments must be made to the existing pigmenting system in order to adequately match the skin colours of the study population. Clinical significance The creation of a shade guide and a collection of intrinsic pigments representing the realm of human facial skin colours would greatly decrease the time a patient must sit while the clinician is obtaining an acceptable colour match for the silicone to be used for processing the final prosthesis, thereby increasing both patient satisfaction and clinician productivity.

KW - Aesthetics

KW - Colour differences

KW - Maxillofacial elastomer

KW - Prosthesis colouring

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84887229143&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84887229143&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jdent.2013.07.010

DO - 10.1016/j.jdent.2013.07.010

M3 - Article

VL - 41

SP - 986

EP - 991

JO - Journal of Dentistry

JF - Journal of Dentistry

SN - 0300-5712

IS - 11

ER -