Choosing the lesser of two evils, the better of two goods

Specifying the roles of ventromedial prefrontal cortex and dorsal anterior cingulate in object choice

Karina Blair, Abigail A. Marsh, John Morton, Meena Vythilingam, Matthew Jones, Krystal Mondillo, Daniel C. Pine, Wayne C. Drevets, Robert James Blair

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

108 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) and dorsal anterior cingulate cortices (ACd) are considered important for reward-based decision making. However, work distinguishing their individual functional contributions has only begun. One aspect of decision making that has received little attention is that making the right choice often translates to making the better choice. Thus, response choice often occurs in situations where both options are desirable (e.g., choosing between mousse au chocolat or crème caramel cheesecake from a menu) or, alternatively, in situations where both options are undesirable. Moreover, response choice is easier when the reinforcements associated with the objects are far apart, rather than close together, in value. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging to delineate the functional roles of the vmPFC and ACd by investigating these two aspects of decision making: (1) decision form (i.e., choosing between two objects to gain the greater reward or the lesser punishment), and (2) between-object reinforcement distance (i.e., the difference in reinforcements associated with the two objects). Blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) responses within the ACd and vmPFC were both related to decision form but differentially. Whereas ACd showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the lesser punishment, vmPFC showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the greater reward. Moreover, vmPFC was sensitive to reinforcement expectations associated with both the chosen and the forgone choice. In contrast, BOLD responses within ACd, but not vmPFC, related to between-object reinforcement distance, increasing as the distance between the reinforcements of the two objects decreased. These data are interpreted with reference to models of ACd and vmPFC functioning.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)11379-11386
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of Neuroscience
Volume26
Issue number44
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2006

Fingerprint

Gyrus Cinguli
Prefrontal Cortex
Reward
Decision Making
Punishment
Oxygen
Reinforcement (Psychology)
Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Keywords

  • ACd
  • Decision
  • Punishment
  • Reward
  • fMRI
  • vmPFC

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neuroscience(all)

Cite this

Choosing the lesser of two evils, the better of two goods : Specifying the roles of ventromedial prefrontal cortex and dorsal anterior cingulate in object choice. / Blair, Karina; Marsh, Abigail A.; Morton, John; Vythilingam, Meena; Jones, Matthew; Mondillo, Krystal; Pine, Daniel C.; Drevets, Wayne C.; Blair, Robert James.

In: Journal of Neuroscience, Vol. 26, No. 44, 01.11.2006, p. 11379-11386.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Blair, Karina ; Marsh, Abigail A. ; Morton, John ; Vythilingam, Meena ; Jones, Matthew ; Mondillo, Krystal ; Pine, Daniel C. ; Drevets, Wayne C. ; Blair, Robert James. / Choosing the lesser of two evils, the better of two goods : Specifying the roles of ventromedial prefrontal cortex and dorsal anterior cingulate in object choice. In: Journal of Neuroscience. 2006 ; Vol. 26, No. 44. pp. 11379-11386.
@article{1202cc5eb26244648ee3b467a1f9ed49,
title = "Choosing the lesser of two evils, the better of two goods: Specifying the roles of ventromedial prefrontal cortex and dorsal anterior cingulate in object choice",
abstract = "The ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) and dorsal anterior cingulate cortices (ACd) are considered important for reward-based decision making. However, work distinguishing their individual functional contributions has only begun. One aspect of decision making that has received little attention is that making the right choice often translates to making the better choice. Thus, response choice often occurs in situations where both options are desirable (e.g., choosing between mousse au chocolat or cr{\`e}me caramel cheesecake from a menu) or, alternatively, in situations where both options are undesirable. Moreover, response choice is easier when the reinforcements associated with the objects are far apart, rather than close together, in value. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging to delineate the functional roles of the vmPFC and ACd by investigating these two aspects of decision making: (1) decision form (i.e., choosing between two objects to gain the greater reward or the lesser punishment), and (2) between-object reinforcement distance (i.e., the difference in reinforcements associated with the two objects). Blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) responses within the ACd and vmPFC were both related to decision form but differentially. Whereas ACd showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the lesser punishment, vmPFC showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the greater reward. Moreover, vmPFC was sensitive to reinforcement expectations associated with both the chosen and the forgone choice. In contrast, BOLD responses within ACd, but not vmPFC, related to between-object reinforcement distance, increasing as the distance between the reinforcements of the two objects decreased. These data are interpreted with reference to models of ACd and vmPFC functioning.",
keywords = "ACd, Decision, Punishment, Reward, fMRI, vmPFC",
author = "Karina Blair and Marsh, {Abigail A.} and John Morton and Meena Vythilingam and Matthew Jones and Krystal Mondillo and Pine, {Daniel C.} and Drevets, {Wayne C.} and Blair, {Robert James}",
year = "2006",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1640-06.2006",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "26",
pages = "11379--11386",
journal = "Journal of Neuroscience",
issn = "0270-6474",
publisher = "Society for Neuroscience",
number = "44",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Choosing the lesser of two evils, the better of two goods

T2 - Specifying the roles of ventromedial prefrontal cortex and dorsal anterior cingulate in object choice

AU - Blair, Karina

AU - Marsh, Abigail A.

AU - Morton, John

AU - Vythilingam, Meena

AU - Jones, Matthew

AU - Mondillo, Krystal

AU - Pine, Daniel C.

AU - Drevets, Wayne C.

AU - Blair, Robert James

PY - 2006/11/1

Y1 - 2006/11/1

N2 - The ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) and dorsal anterior cingulate cortices (ACd) are considered important for reward-based decision making. However, work distinguishing their individual functional contributions has only begun. One aspect of decision making that has received little attention is that making the right choice often translates to making the better choice. Thus, response choice often occurs in situations where both options are desirable (e.g., choosing between mousse au chocolat or crème caramel cheesecake from a menu) or, alternatively, in situations where both options are undesirable. Moreover, response choice is easier when the reinforcements associated with the objects are far apart, rather than close together, in value. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging to delineate the functional roles of the vmPFC and ACd by investigating these two aspects of decision making: (1) decision form (i.e., choosing between two objects to gain the greater reward or the lesser punishment), and (2) between-object reinforcement distance (i.e., the difference in reinforcements associated with the two objects). Blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) responses within the ACd and vmPFC were both related to decision form but differentially. Whereas ACd showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the lesser punishment, vmPFC showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the greater reward. Moreover, vmPFC was sensitive to reinforcement expectations associated with both the chosen and the forgone choice. In contrast, BOLD responses within ACd, but not vmPFC, related to between-object reinforcement distance, increasing as the distance between the reinforcements of the two objects decreased. These data are interpreted with reference to models of ACd and vmPFC functioning.

AB - The ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) and dorsal anterior cingulate cortices (ACd) are considered important for reward-based decision making. However, work distinguishing their individual functional contributions has only begun. One aspect of decision making that has received little attention is that making the right choice often translates to making the better choice. Thus, response choice often occurs in situations where both options are desirable (e.g., choosing between mousse au chocolat or crème caramel cheesecake from a menu) or, alternatively, in situations where both options are undesirable. Moreover, response choice is easier when the reinforcements associated with the objects are far apart, rather than close together, in value. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging to delineate the functional roles of the vmPFC and ACd by investigating these two aspects of decision making: (1) decision form (i.e., choosing between two objects to gain the greater reward or the lesser punishment), and (2) between-object reinforcement distance (i.e., the difference in reinforcements associated with the two objects). Blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) responses within the ACd and vmPFC were both related to decision form but differentially. Whereas ACd showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the lesser punishment, vmPFC showed greater responses when deciding between objects to gain the greater reward. Moreover, vmPFC was sensitive to reinforcement expectations associated with both the chosen and the forgone choice. In contrast, BOLD responses within ACd, but not vmPFC, related to between-object reinforcement distance, increasing as the distance between the reinforcements of the two objects decreased. These data are interpreted with reference to models of ACd and vmPFC functioning.

KW - ACd

KW - Decision

KW - Punishment

KW - Reward

KW - fMRI

KW - vmPFC

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33750952524&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33750952524&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1640-06.2006

DO - 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1640-06.2006

M3 - Article

VL - 26

SP - 11379

EP - 11386

JO - Journal of Neuroscience

JF - Journal of Neuroscience

SN - 0270-6474

IS - 44

ER -