Agency and social constraint among victims of domestic minor sex trafficking: A method for measuring free will

Bilal Khan, Hsuan Wei Lee, Courtney R. Thrash, Kirk Dombrowski

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Human agency has been a focus of philosophical and sociological concern from early debates about “free will” to recent themes in poststructuralism. Debates over the proper understanding of structure, agency, and constraint are hindered by the fact that few if any empirical measures of these concepts have been proposed. As sociologists have long recognized, the total results of the decisions of a group's members can be viewed as a distribution, and parameters can be fit to obtain a description of observed distributions. Here we propose the use of negative binomial curve to model population survival outcomes, and suggest that the parameters of such a curve represent reasonable surrogates for measures of agency, opportunity, and constraint when the decision process can be thought of as akin to a Bernoulli process. To provide an illustration of this approach, we discuss participation of legal minors in commercial sex (commonly referred to as victims of domestic minor sex trafficking (VDMST) or commercially sexually exploited children (CSEC)). In popular and advocacy-based accounts, considerable focus has been placed on the relative powerlessness of female VDMST. Using the proposed modeling technique, we test the extent to which male versus female VDMST appear to possess greater agency (or function under more limiting constraint) when deciding whether to remain in sex work or “leave the life”. Contrary to existing literature, our results indicate that male and female underage sex workers are experiencing similar levels of agency, and differ mainly in opportunity, and constraint. Other individual circumstances are shown to contribute to varying levels of agency and constraint among sex workers, including street work status, community trouble, drug use, and the availability of an alternative income. Guildenstern: Inside where nothing shows, I am the essence of a manspinning double-headed coins, and betting against himself in privateatonement for an unremembered past. Tom Stoppard, “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead”

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)144-156
Number of pages13
JournalSocial Science Research
Volume76
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 2018

Fingerprint

freedom of will
worker
underage
group membership
sociologist
drug use
income
participation
community

Keywords

  • Agency
  • Bernoulli trials
  • Computational sociology
  • Constraint
  • Sex trafficking

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • Sociology and Political Science

Cite this

Agency and social constraint among victims of domestic minor sex trafficking : A method for measuring free will. / Khan, Bilal; Lee, Hsuan Wei; Thrash, Courtney R.; Dombrowski, Kirk.

In: Social Science Research, Vol. 76, 11.2018, p. 144-156.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{cf99e17544e748b8a3bad19cca11a8bd,
title = "Agency and social constraint among victims of domestic minor sex trafficking: A method for measuring free will",
abstract = "Human agency has been a focus of philosophical and sociological concern from early debates about “free will” to recent themes in poststructuralism. Debates over the proper understanding of structure, agency, and constraint are hindered by the fact that few if any empirical measures of these concepts have been proposed. As sociologists have long recognized, the total results of the decisions of a group's members can be viewed as a distribution, and parameters can be fit to obtain a description of observed distributions. Here we propose the use of negative binomial curve to model population survival outcomes, and suggest that the parameters of such a curve represent reasonable surrogates for measures of agency, opportunity, and constraint when the decision process can be thought of as akin to a Bernoulli process. To provide an illustration of this approach, we discuss participation of legal minors in commercial sex (commonly referred to as victims of domestic minor sex trafficking (VDMST) or commercially sexually exploited children (CSEC)). In popular and advocacy-based accounts, considerable focus has been placed on the relative powerlessness of female VDMST. Using the proposed modeling technique, we test the extent to which male versus female VDMST appear to possess greater agency (or function under more limiting constraint) when deciding whether to remain in sex work or “leave the life”. Contrary to existing literature, our results indicate that male and female underage sex workers are experiencing similar levels of agency, and differ mainly in opportunity, and constraint. Other individual circumstances are shown to contribute to varying levels of agency and constraint among sex workers, including street work status, community trouble, drug use, and the availability of an alternative income. Guildenstern: Inside where nothing shows, I am the essence of a manspinning double-headed coins, and betting against himself in privateatonement for an unremembered past. Tom Stoppard, “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead”",
keywords = "Agency, Bernoulli trials, Computational sociology, Constraint, Sex trafficking",
author = "Bilal Khan and Lee, {Hsuan Wei} and Thrash, {Courtney R.} and Kirk Dombrowski",
year = "2018",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1016/j.ssresearch.2018.06.007",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "76",
pages = "144--156",
journal = "Social Science Research",
issn = "0049-089X",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Agency and social constraint among victims of domestic minor sex trafficking

T2 - A method for measuring free will

AU - Khan, Bilal

AU - Lee, Hsuan Wei

AU - Thrash, Courtney R.

AU - Dombrowski, Kirk

PY - 2018/11

Y1 - 2018/11

N2 - Human agency has been a focus of philosophical and sociological concern from early debates about “free will” to recent themes in poststructuralism. Debates over the proper understanding of structure, agency, and constraint are hindered by the fact that few if any empirical measures of these concepts have been proposed. As sociologists have long recognized, the total results of the decisions of a group's members can be viewed as a distribution, and parameters can be fit to obtain a description of observed distributions. Here we propose the use of negative binomial curve to model population survival outcomes, and suggest that the parameters of such a curve represent reasonable surrogates for measures of agency, opportunity, and constraint when the decision process can be thought of as akin to a Bernoulli process. To provide an illustration of this approach, we discuss participation of legal minors in commercial sex (commonly referred to as victims of domestic minor sex trafficking (VDMST) or commercially sexually exploited children (CSEC)). In popular and advocacy-based accounts, considerable focus has been placed on the relative powerlessness of female VDMST. Using the proposed modeling technique, we test the extent to which male versus female VDMST appear to possess greater agency (or function under more limiting constraint) when deciding whether to remain in sex work or “leave the life”. Contrary to existing literature, our results indicate that male and female underage sex workers are experiencing similar levels of agency, and differ mainly in opportunity, and constraint. Other individual circumstances are shown to contribute to varying levels of agency and constraint among sex workers, including street work status, community trouble, drug use, and the availability of an alternative income. Guildenstern: Inside where nothing shows, I am the essence of a manspinning double-headed coins, and betting against himself in privateatonement for an unremembered past. Tom Stoppard, “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead”

AB - Human agency has been a focus of philosophical and sociological concern from early debates about “free will” to recent themes in poststructuralism. Debates over the proper understanding of structure, agency, and constraint are hindered by the fact that few if any empirical measures of these concepts have been proposed. As sociologists have long recognized, the total results of the decisions of a group's members can be viewed as a distribution, and parameters can be fit to obtain a description of observed distributions. Here we propose the use of negative binomial curve to model population survival outcomes, and suggest that the parameters of such a curve represent reasonable surrogates for measures of agency, opportunity, and constraint when the decision process can be thought of as akin to a Bernoulli process. To provide an illustration of this approach, we discuss participation of legal minors in commercial sex (commonly referred to as victims of domestic minor sex trafficking (VDMST) or commercially sexually exploited children (CSEC)). In popular and advocacy-based accounts, considerable focus has been placed on the relative powerlessness of female VDMST. Using the proposed modeling technique, we test the extent to which male versus female VDMST appear to possess greater agency (or function under more limiting constraint) when deciding whether to remain in sex work or “leave the life”. Contrary to existing literature, our results indicate that male and female underage sex workers are experiencing similar levels of agency, and differ mainly in opportunity, and constraint. Other individual circumstances are shown to contribute to varying levels of agency and constraint among sex workers, including street work status, community trouble, drug use, and the availability of an alternative income. Guildenstern: Inside where nothing shows, I am the essence of a manspinning double-headed coins, and betting against himself in privateatonement for an unremembered past. Tom Stoppard, “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead”

KW - Agency

KW - Bernoulli trials

KW - Computational sociology

KW - Constraint

KW - Sex trafficking

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85051137138&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85051137138&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2018.06.007

DO - 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2018.06.007

M3 - Article

C2 - 30268276

AN - SCOPUS:85051137138

VL - 76

SP - 144

EP - 156

JO - Social Science Research

JF - Social Science Research

SN - 0049-089X

ER -