Advanced fingerprinting of high-quality cocoa: Challenges in transferring methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two dimensional gas chromatography

Federico Magagna, Erica Liberto, Stephen E. Reichenbach, Qingping Tao, Andrea Carretta, Luigi Cobelli, Matthew Giardina, Carlo Bicchi, Chiara Cordero

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The possibility to transfer methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatographic (GC × GC) platforms opens interesting perspectives for routine analysis of complex samples. Flow modulated platforms avoid the use of cryogenics, thereby simplifying laboratory operations and analyst supervision during intensive analytical sessions. This study evaluates the feasibility of transferring a fingerprinting method capable of classifying and discriminating cocoa samples based on the volatiles fraction composition according to their origin and processing steps. Previously developed principles of GC × GC method translation are applied to an original fingerprinting method, developed for a loop-type thermal modulated GC × GC–MS system, to engineer a method for a reverse-injection differential flow modulated platform (GC × 2GC–MS/FID) with a dual-parallel secondary column and dual detection. Effective method translation preserves analytes elution order, 1D resolution, and 2D pattern coherence. The experimental results confirm the feasibility of translating fingerprinting method conditions while preserving the informative power of 2D peak patterns for sample classification and discrimination. Correct translation enables effective transfer of metadata (e.g., compound names and MS fragmentation patterns) by automatic template transformation and matching from the original/reference method to its translated counterpart. Although the adoption of a narrow bore (i.e. 0.1 mm dc) column in the first-dimension enabled operation under close-to-optimal conditions with the differential-flow modulation platform, due to the dual-parallel columns in the second-dimension, it resulted in lower overall method sensitivity. Nevertheless, fingerprinting accuracy was preserved and most of the key-aroma compounds and technological markers were effectively mapped, thus limiting the loss of fingerprinting information.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)122-136
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of Chromatography A
Volume1536
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 9 2018

Fingerprint

Cocoa
Gas chromatography
Gas Chromatography
Hot Temperature
Gases
Metadata
Cryogenics
Modulation
Engineers
Processing
Chemical analysis
Translating
Feasibility Studies
Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry
Names

Keywords

  • Advanced fingerprinting
  • Comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography–mass spectrometry and flame ionization detection
  • Method translation
  • Reverse-inject differential flow modulation
  • Template matching functions
  • Theobroma cacao

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Analytical Chemistry
  • Biochemistry
  • Organic Chemistry

Cite this

Advanced fingerprinting of high-quality cocoa : Challenges in transferring methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two dimensional gas chromatography. / Magagna, Federico; Liberto, Erica; Reichenbach, Stephen E.; Tao, Qingping; Carretta, Andrea; Cobelli, Luigi; Giardina, Matthew; Bicchi, Carlo; Cordero, Chiara.

In: Journal of Chromatography A, Vol. 1536, 09.02.2018, p. 122-136.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Magagna, Federico ; Liberto, Erica ; Reichenbach, Stephen E. ; Tao, Qingping ; Carretta, Andrea ; Cobelli, Luigi ; Giardina, Matthew ; Bicchi, Carlo ; Cordero, Chiara. / Advanced fingerprinting of high-quality cocoa : Challenges in transferring methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two dimensional gas chromatography. In: Journal of Chromatography A. 2018 ; Vol. 1536. pp. 122-136.
@article{befc4d0fd45e442ab6d8b3b45450c867,
title = "Advanced fingerprinting of high-quality cocoa: Challenges in transferring methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two dimensional gas chromatography",
abstract = "The possibility to transfer methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatographic (GC × GC) platforms opens interesting perspectives for routine analysis of complex samples. Flow modulated platforms avoid the use of cryogenics, thereby simplifying laboratory operations and analyst supervision during intensive analytical sessions. This study evaluates the feasibility of transferring a fingerprinting method capable of classifying and discriminating cocoa samples based on the volatiles fraction composition according to their origin and processing steps. Previously developed principles of GC × GC method translation are applied to an original fingerprinting method, developed for a loop-type thermal modulated GC × GC–MS system, to engineer a method for a reverse-injection differential flow modulated platform (GC × 2GC–MS/FID) with a dual-parallel secondary column and dual detection. Effective method translation preserves analytes elution order, 1D resolution, and 2D pattern coherence. The experimental results confirm the feasibility of translating fingerprinting method conditions while preserving the informative power of 2D peak patterns for sample classification and discrimination. Correct translation enables effective transfer of metadata (e.g., compound names and MS fragmentation patterns) by automatic template transformation and matching from the original/reference method to its translated counterpart. Although the adoption of a narrow bore (i.e. 0.1 mm dc) column in the first-dimension enabled operation under close-to-optimal conditions with the differential-flow modulation platform, due to the dual-parallel columns in the second-dimension, it resulted in lower overall method sensitivity. Nevertheless, fingerprinting accuracy was preserved and most of the key-aroma compounds and technological markers were effectively mapped, thus limiting the loss of fingerprinting information.",
keywords = "Advanced fingerprinting, Comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography–mass spectrometry and flame ionization detection, Method translation, Reverse-inject differential flow modulation, Template matching functions, Theobroma cacao",
author = "Federico Magagna and Erica Liberto and Reichenbach, {Stephen E.} and Qingping Tao and Andrea Carretta and Luigi Cobelli and Matthew Giardina and Carlo Bicchi and Chiara Cordero",
year = "2018",
month = "2",
day = "9",
doi = "10.1016/j.chroma.2017.07.014",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "1536",
pages = "122--136",
journal = "Journal of Chromatography A",
issn = "0021-9673",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Advanced fingerprinting of high-quality cocoa

T2 - Challenges in transferring methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two dimensional gas chromatography

AU - Magagna, Federico

AU - Liberto, Erica

AU - Reichenbach, Stephen E.

AU - Tao, Qingping

AU - Carretta, Andrea

AU - Cobelli, Luigi

AU - Giardina, Matthew

AU - Bicchi, Carlo

AU - Cordero, Chiara

PY - 2018/2/9

Y1 - 2018/2/9

N2 - The possibility to transfer methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatographic (GC × GC) platforms opens interesting perspectives for routine analysis of complex samples. Flow modulated platforms avoid the use of cryogenics, thereby simplifying laboratory operations and analyst supervision during intensive analytical sessions. This study evaluates the feasibility of transferring a fingerprinting method capable of classifying and discriminating cocoa samples based on the volatiles fraction composition according to their origin and processing steps. Previously developed principles of GC × GC method translation are applied to an original fingerprinting method, developed for a loop-type thermal modulated GC × GC–MS system, to engineer a method for a reverse-injection differential flow modulated platform (GC × 2GC–MS/FID) with a dual-parallel secondary column and dual detection. Effective method translation preserves analytes elution order, 1D resolution, and 2D pattern coherence. The experimental results confirm the feasibility of translating fingerprinting method conditions while preserving the informative power of 2D peak patterns for sample classification and discrimination. Correct translation enables effective transfer of metadata (e.g., compound names and MS fragmentation patterns) by automatic template transformation and matching from the original/reference method to its translated counterpart. Although the adoption of a narrow bore (i.e. 0.1 mm dc) column in the first-dimension enabled operation under close-to-optimal conditions with the differential-flow modulation platform, due to the dual-parallel columns in the second-dimension, it resulted in lower overall method sensitivity. Nevertheless, fingerprinting accuracy was preserved and most of the key-aroma compounds and technological markers were effectively mapped, thus limiting the loss of fingerprinting information.

AB - The possibility to transfer methods from thermal to differential-flow modulated comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatographic (GC × GC) platforms opens interesting perspectives for routine analysis of complex samples. Flow modulated platforms avoid the use of cryogenics, thereby simplifying laboratory operations and analyst supervision during intensive analytical sessions. This study evaluates the feasibility of transferring a fingerprinting method capable of classifying and discriminating cocoa samples based on the volatiles fraction composition according to their origin and processing steps. Previously developed principles of GC × GC method translation are applied to an original fingerprinting method, developed for a loop-type thermal modulated GC × GC–MS system, to engineer a method for a reverse-injection differential flow modulated platform (GC × 2GC–MS/FID) with a dual-parallel secondary column and dual detection. Effective method translation preserves analytes elution order, 1D resolution, and 2D pattern coherence. The experimental results confirm the feasibility of translating fingerprinting method conditions while preserving the informative power of 2D peak patterns for sample classification and discrimination. Correct translation enables effective transfer of metadata (e.g., compound names and MS fragmentation patterns) by automatic template transformation and matching from the original/reference method to its translated counterpart. Although the adoption of a narrow bore (i.e. 0.1 mm dc) column in the first-dimension enabled operation under close-to-optimal conditions with the differential-flow modulation platform, due to the dual-parallel columns in the second-dimension, it resulted in lower overall method sensitivity. Nevertheless, fingerprinting accuracy was preserved and most of the key-aroma compounds and technological markers were effectively mapped, thus limiting the loss of fingerprinting information.

KW - Advanced fingerprinting

KW - Comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography–mass spectrometry and flame ionization detection

KW - Method translation

KW - Reverse-inject differential flow modulation

KW - Template matching functions

KW - Theobroma cacao

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85026317947&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85026317947&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.chroma.2017.07.014

DO - 10.1016/j.chroma.2017.07.014

M3 - Article

C2 - 28760605

AN - SCOPUS:85026317947

VL - 1536

SP - 122

EP - 136

JO - Journal of Chromatography A

JF - Journal of Chromatography A

SN - 0021-9673

ER -