Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin

Andrew J. Tyre, James T. Peterson, Sarah J. Converse, Tiffany Bogich, Damien Miller, Max Post van der Burg, Carmen Thomas, Ralph Thompson, Jeri Wood, Donna C. Brewer, Michael C. Runge

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The bull trout Salvelinus confluentus, a stream-living salmonid distributed in drainages of the northwestern United States, is listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act because of rangewide declines. One proposed recovery action is the reconnection of tributaries in the Lemhi Basin. Past water use policies in this core area disconnected headwater spawning sites from downstream habitat and have led to the loss of migratory life history forms. We developed an adaptive management framework to analyze which types of streams should be prioritized for reconnection under a proposed Habitat Conservation Plan. We developed a Stochastic Dynamic Program that identified optimal policies over time under four different assumptions about the nature of the migratory behavior and the effects of brook trout Salvelinus fontinalis on subpopulations of bull trout. In general, given the current state of the system and the uncertainties about the dynamics, the optimal policy would be to connect streams that are currently occupied by bull trout. We also estimated the value of information as the difference between absolute certainty about which of our four assumptions were correct, and a model averaged optimization assuming no knowledge. Overall there is little to be gained by learning about the dynamics of the system in its current state, although in other parts of the state space reducing uncertainties about the system would be very valuable. We also conducted a sensitivity analysis; the optimal decision at the current state does not change even when parameter values are changed up to 75% of the baseline values. Overall, the exercise demonstrates that it is possible to apply adaptive management principles to threatened and endangered species, but logistical and data availability constraints make detailed analyses difficult.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)262-281
Number of pages20
JournalJournal of Fish and Wildlife Management
Volume2
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 1 2011

Fingerprint

Salvelinus confluentus
adaptive management
basins
Salvelinus fontinalis
basin
endangered species
habitat conservation
Endangered Species Act
migratory behavior
uncertainty
salmonid
subpopulation
Northwestern United States
headwater
water use
sensitivity analysis
tributary
spawning
life history
threatened species

Keywords

  • Migratory
  • Occupancy
  • Patch network model
  • Salvelinus confluentus
  • Salvelinus fontinalis
  • Stochastic dynamic programming

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Ecology
  • Animal Science and Zoology
  • Nature and Landscape Conservation

Cite this

Tyre, A. J., Peterson, J. T., Converse, S. J., Bogich, T., Miller, D., Post van der Burg, M., ... Runge, M. C. (2011). Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin. Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management, 2(2), 262-281. https://doi.org/10.3996/022011-JFWM-012

Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin. / Tyre, Andrew J.; Peterson, James T.; Converse, Sarah J.; Bogich, Tiffany; Miller, Damien; Post van der Burg, Max; Thomas, Carmen; Thompson, Ralph; Wood, Jeri; Brewer, Donna C.; Runge, Michael C.

In: Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management, Vol. 2, No. 2, 01.12.2011, p. 262-281.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Tyre, AJ, Peterson, JT, Converse, SJ, Bogich, T, Miller, D, Post van der Burg, M, Thomas, C, Thompson, R, Wood, J, Brewer, DC & Runge, MC 2011, 'Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin', Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 262-281. https://doi.org/10.3996/022011-JFWM-012
Tyre AJ, Peterson JT, Converse SJ, Bogich T, Miller D, Post van der Burg M et al. Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin. Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management. 2011 Dec 1;2(2):262-281. https://doi.org/10.3996/022011-JFWM-012
Tyre, Andrew J. ; Peterson, James T. ; Converse, Sarah J. ; Bogich, Tiffany ; Miller, Damien ; Post van der Burg, Max ; Thomas, Carmen ; Thompson, Ralph ; Wood, Jeri ; Brewer, Donna C. ; Runge, Michael C. / Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin. In: Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management. 2011 ; Vol. 2, No. 2. pp. 262-281.
@article{4fb0a427ee184ac99093c01f8b84218e,
title = "Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin",
abstract = "The bull trout Salvelinus confluentus, a stream-living salmonid distributed in drainages of the northwestern United States, is listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act because of rangewide declines. One proposed recovery action is the reconnection of tributaries in the Lemhi Basin. Past water use policies in this core area disconnected headwater spawning sites from downstream habitat and have led to the loss of migratory life history forms. We developed an adaptive management framework to analyze which types of streams should be prioritized for reconnection under a proposed Habitat Conservation Plan. We developed a Stochastic Dynamic Program that identified optimal policies over time under four different assumptions about the nature of the migratory behavior and the effects of brook trout Salvelinus fontinalis on subpopulations of bull trout. In general, given the current state of the system and the uncertainties about the dynamics, the optimal policy would be to connect streams that are currently occupied by bull trout. We also estimated the value of information as the difference between absolute certainty about which of our four assumptions were correct, and a model averaged optimization assuming no knowledge. Overall there is little to be gained by learning about the dynamics of the system in its current state, although in other parts of the state space reducing uncertainties about the system would be very valuable. We also conducted a sensitivity analysis; the optimal decision at the current state does not change even when parameter values are changed up to 75{\%} of the baseline values. Overall, the exercise demonstrates that it is possible to apply adaptive management principles to threatened and endangered species, but logistical and data availability constraints make detailed analyses difficult.",
keywords = "Migratory, Occupancy, Patch network model, Salvelinus confluentus, Salvelinus fontinalis, Stochastic dynamic programming",
author = "Tyre, {Andrew J.} and Peterson, {James T.} and Converse, {Sarah J.} and Tiffany Bogich and Damien Miller and {Post van der Burg}, Max and Carmen Thomas and Ralph Thompson and Jeri Wood and Brewer, {Donna C.} and Runge, {Michael C.}",
year = "2011",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3996/022011-JFWM-012",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "2",
pages = "262--281",
journal = "Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management",
issn = "1944-687X",
publisher = "U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Adaptive management of bull trout populations in the Lemhi Basin

AU - Tyre, Andrew J.

AU - Peterson, James T.

AU - Converse, Sarah J.

AU - Bogich, Tiffany

AU - Miller, Damien

AU - Post van der Burg, Max

AU - Thomas, Carmen

AU - Thompson, Ralph

AU - Wood, Jeri

AU - Brewer, Donna C.

AU - Runge, Michael C.

PY - 2011/12/1

Y1 - 2011/12/1

N2 - The bull trout Salvelinus confluentus, a stream-living salmonid distributed in drainages of the northwestern United States, is listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act because of rangewide declines. One proposed recovery action is the reconnection of tributaries in the Lemhi Basin. Past water use policies in this core area disconnected headwater spawning sites from downstream habitat and have led to the loss of migratory life history forms. We developed an adaptive management framework to analyze which types of streams should be prioritized for reconnection under a proposed Habitat Conservation Plan. We developed a Stochastic Dynamic Program that identified optimal policies over time under four different assumptions about the nature of the migratory behavior and the effects of brook trout Salvelinus fontinalis on subpopulations of bull trout. In general, given the current state of the system and the uncertainties about the dynamics, the optimal policy would be to connect streams that are currently occupied by bull trout. We also estimated the value of information as the difference between absolute certainty about which of our four assumptions were correct, and a model averaged optimization assuming no knowledge. Overall there is little to be gained by learning about the dynamics of the system in its current state, although in other parts of the state space reducing uncertainties about the system would be very valuable. We also conducted a sensitivity analysis; the optimal decision at the current state does not change even when parameter values are changed up to 75% of the baseline values. Overall, the exercise demonstrates that it is possible to apply adaptive management principles to threatened and endangered species, but logistical and data availability constraints make detailed analyses difficult.

AB - The bull trout Salvelinus confluentus, a stream-living salmonid distributed in drainages of the northwestern United States, is listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act because of rangewide declines. One proposed recovery action is the reconnection of tributaries in the Lemhi Basin. Past water use policies in this core area disconnected headwater spawning sites from downstream habitat and have led to the loss of migratory life history forms. We developed an adaptive management framework to analyze which types of streams should be prioritized for reconnection under a proposed Habitat Conservation Plan. We developed a Stochastic Dynamic Program that identified optimal policies over time under four different assumptions about the nature of the migratory behavior and the effects of brook trout Salvelinus fontinalis on subpopulations of bull trout. In general, given the current state of the system and the uncertainties about the dynamics, the optimal policy would be to connect streams that are currently occupied by bull trout. We also estimated the value of information as the difference between absolute certainty about which of our four assumptions were correct, and a model averaged optimization assuming no knowledge. Overall there is little to be gained by learning about the dynamics of the system in its current state, although in other parts of the state space reducing uncertainties about the system would be very valuable. We also conducted a sensitivity analysis; the optimal decision at the current state does not change even when parameter values are changed up to 75% of the baseline values. Overall, the exercise demonstrates that it is possible to apply adaptive management principles to threatened and endangered species, but logistical and data availability constraints make detailed analyses difficult.

KW - Migratory

KW - Occupancy

KW - Patch network model

KW - Salvelinus confluentus

KW - Salvelinus fontinalis

KW - Stochastic dynamic programming

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84868144945&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84868144945&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3996/022011-JFWM-012

DO - 10.3996/022011-JFWM-012

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84868144945

VL - 2

SP - 262

EP - 281

JO - Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management

JF - Journal of Fish and Wildlife Management

SN - 1944-687X

IS - 2

ER -